Saturday, 27 February 2021

Sadhanai Saram (Dnyana Bodham), Atma vichar patikam, forty verses of sanyasi

https://www.happinessofbeing.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/09/Sadhanai_Saram-4.pdf

127 pgs

 16

4. The Grace of Sri Ramana

 6. Sri Ramana, the Bestower of Grace, will never give the least dissatisfaction to those who weepingly pray to Him, “Make me Your possession.”

I know that our Lord uses countless inexpressible tricks in order to protect and save those who have become His slaves. 

7. What our Lord uses to save us are tricks of Grace. 

Even by the skill of our intellects, it is impossible for us to know all those tricks. 


If He wishes, even an ocean will enter and disappear into a mustard seed. Therefore, as soon as the glance of Sri Ramana’s Grace falls upon us, the Supreme Reality will be revealed. 

8. Since He is not bound by time or even by the limitation of place, He will not wait for some suitable time or suitable place to bestow His Grace upon His devotees. He has far greater compassion than even a compassionate mother, who has no plan that she will give her baby milk to drink only when it cries (and hence, even without our crying for it, He will bestow His Grace upon us of His own accord). 

9. O Bhagavan, innumerable are the wrongs (the mistakes and misfortunes) from which I, this poor creature, have escaped by Your Grace unknown to myself. You know all of them, but I do not know anything except enjoying the bliss of being saved by Your Grace. 

10. O Sri Ramana, those who have taken refuge at Your Feet are protected perfectly not only on one or two occasions but on more than a crore of occasions. From many incidents that happen in their life, this is a truth that is clearly known to the hearts of Your devotees


 11. The state of abiding in the Heart as the Heart as it is (that is, as the adjunctless and thought free existence-consciousness “I am”) is the ineffable and most excellent state. 

He, who nurtures the fruit of such Self-abidance by sowing the seed of clarity of mind and by watering it with divine Grace, is only our Self-realized Guru, Sri Ramana.

12. We and all our possessions, beginning with the body, are in truth only the possessions of Sri Ramana. When the responsibility of saving us and protecting our possessions is borne by Him alone, why should we worry about anything in our life on this earth thinking it to be either pleasure or pain? Where is any such thing as wrong, evil, harm or suffering now?

 ..

5. All That He Does is Happiness for Me 

13. The almighty Sri Ramana, who exists within the heart of everyone, who unfailingly helps me at all times, and who cannot be banished from my mind even for a moment, has brought me close to Him only to take me as His slave. 

Therefore, whatever He now does with me is only happiness for me; how can anything that He does hereafter appear to me as something undesirable or painful? 

..


6. Leave it to Him 

14. He knows the best of all, 

 Leave it to Him, be calm; 

 Believe Him most of all, 

 Then rests the mental storm. 

..

7. Grace Alone is of Prime Importance 

15. The ego is only a trivial entity; besides, it is unreal (asat) and powerless (asakta). It is a mere adjunct which rises and subsides. Therefore, what foolishness it is to think, “The spiritual practice (sadhana) done by the strength of this ego will by itself bestow the goal of life; the supreme power of divine Grace is not of any consequence (and is not necessary in order for one to attain the goal)”! 

Note: Not believing Grace, but thinking one’s own individual effort alone to be of very great consequence, is mere foolishness.

16. Is not the unreal help which one unreal man renders to another unreal man, experienced by everyone in this world as real? Therefore, O Sadguru,

the embodiment of Grace, the sole reality, is it impossible for You to save me by dispelling the unreal ego? What doubt or wonder is there in Your being able to help me thus? 

Note: A man or jiva is merely an unreal appearance, and hence whatever help he may seem to render to another man is also unreal.

 But when such unreal help rendered by an unreal man is experienced by everyone as real, why should we doubt the ability of the Sadguru, who alone is truly real, to render us the real help of destroying the unreal ego? Such help from the Sadguru will certainly be experienced by us as more real than the help that we feel is rendered to us by others. 

17. Unless our Lord, Sri Ramana, who is the form of God, Himself bestows His divine Grace, who can by his own effort attain that heroic state of firmly abiding as Self, having clearly known one consciousness other than the body to be the real “I”? 

..............

8. What is Worthy to be Desired? 

18. The great wealth that exists in enlightened sages (Jnanis) is only the subtle secret of how to be still, abiding in perfect peace as the mere thought free existence-consciousness “I am.” Therefore, how wretched it will be if one greedily desires to attain from them mere worldly pleasures, such as gold, wealth or fame, which will only make one suffer in delusion.   

..

9. Sense-Pleasures are Worthless 

19. Instead of eating the fruit that is in your hand, why do you desire to eat the unreal fruit which is seen in a mirror and which is merely a reflection of the fruit in your hand? Is the reflected fruit an object which can be eaten and give real enjoyment? Similarly, instead of drowning deep within the heart by keenly attending to Self and thereby enjoying the bliss of Self which is ever shining there, why do you desire to enjoy the pleasures experienced through the five senses of this perishable body, which are merely an unreal reflection of the true happiness within you?

21

11. The Goal 

21. If we deeply ponder over the natural yearning of all living beings to remove their miseries (through some means or other), it will be decidedly known that the sole aim for which the whole world is striving is only to remain always in perfectly imperishable bliss. 

22. If the people of the world still do not cease making efforts, the conclusion we must come to is, that they have not yet attained perfect happiness, is it not? Whoever among the people has obtained complete contentment and has therefore ceased making any kind of effort is truly one who has attained all that is to be attained.

reworded:

if someone is still making efforts, it means he hasn't yet achieved what he as to achieve.

If he has achieved what he wants to achieve, he will be still. Content.


12. Which Do You Like? 

23. Having limited and transformed oneself into a body, and having transformed the knowledge gathered through the five senses of that body into the world, one sees that world, which is nothing other than one’s own real Self, as objects which are other than oneself, and one is thereby deluded with likes and dislikes for those objects. Such confusion alone is what is called the world-illusion (jagatmaya).  


 24. The non-dual state in which you do not see yourself as the body and as the any objects of the world, and in which you clearly know that that which exists is only you, who are one, this alone is the state of God. 

Whichever you like is possible (that is, by your own unlimited perfect freedom (or paripurnabrahma-swatantra), it is possible for you to remain in whichever one of these two states you like – either in the state of delusion (maya), in which you are deluded by seeing yourself as many, or in the state of God, in which you realize yourself to be the one non-dual reality

R: seeing one and not many = self realn.

You can choose to dwell in reality or illusion.

( the translation is horrible...look for R /reworded)


13. The Nature of Desire 

25. When by one’s own inexpressible power one imaginarily sees the one real Self as many objects (the soul, world and God) and thinks oneself to be one among those objects, then one’s own natural self-love, which transcends thought, will assume the form of a thought and will appear to oneself, the individual who imagines thus, as desires for those objects, which are seemingly other than oneself.

 Note: What is called “love” is truly nothing but the non-dual love (ananya priya), which the real Self has for itself in the state in which it alone exists and shines. And what is called “desire” is nothing but the dual love (anya priya), which springs towards other objects, which are truly not other than Self, in the state in which the one real Self seems to be many objects. Therefore, the only way to put an end to desire is for one, by means of one’s own perfect freedom (brahma-swatantra), to use one’s own inexpressible power to see Self as one and not as many. In order to see Self thus as One, as it ever really is, one must cease attending to the many objects which seem to be other than oneself, and must instead attend only to the first person singular feeling “I”.

 26. Of all things, is not oneself the most beloved? When one limits oneself by imagining oneself to be a body, one sees all these things (the world and God), which are truly nothing but one’s own Self, as objects other than oneself, and hence one has desire for those objects. That desire is only a distorted form of the true self-love that is one’s own very nature. 


27. The love, which one always has for oneself, is not a thought; that supreme love is one’s own real Self that is existence-consciousness-bliss (sat-chitananda). When a wrong knowledge rises in the form of a thought whereby one mistakenly sees the one Self as many objects which are seemingly other than oneself, even the true self-love will become a petty thought in the form of desire. 

28. When self-love, which is not a thought, forsakes its own real nature of mere being and springs towards other things in the form of desires, it becomes ever-moving thoughts. 

When love remains as the thought-free love for Self 

instead of becoming thoughts in the form of desires for other things, 

that state of Self-abidance is true tapas (austerities or severe spiritual discipline).


 29. This original love for Self, which has now become the three desires, will cease to assume the form of thoughts and will remain as supreme bliss only by means of Self-realization, 

the state in which one sees all the five elements and the entire world constituted by those elements, as not other than oneself. 


Note: The three basic human desires are:

 (1) the desire for relationships (uravu-asai), that is, the desire for relatives, wife, husband, children, friends or any kind of human relationship, whether sensual, emotional or otherwise; 

(2) the desire for possessions in any form whatsoever (porul-asai); and

 (3) the desire for praise, that is, the desire for fame, honor, esteem or any kind of appreciation from others (puhazh-asai). The reason for classifying these 

three desires is explained in more detail in verses 102 to 109 of this text.

39

  18. Japa – Repetition of Mantras 

71. The benefit in repeating a holy name of God is not only to gain one-pointedness of mind, but is to surrender oneself to God to such an extent that one’s heart melts and dissolves with ever-brimming love for Him while repeating His name.

72. Thinking once of the name of God with a steady one-pointed mind is more valuable than doing a thousand, thousand (or crores) of repetitions (japa) with a wandering mind. 

But calling intently upon God even once, 

with a mind surging with love for Him, 

is far superior even to doing a million (crore) of japa with a one-pointed mind.  


73. While doing repetition (japa) of the name of God, there is one thing, called “love,” which is to be mingled with it. If one knows correctly the way to do japa uniting love with the name of God, the result attained by that japa will be not only one-pointedness of mind, that japa will bestow upon one the deathless state of union with God.

74. Uniting love with the name of God is giving of oneself, the ego “I,” as an offering to His feet. Love is we, and the name is He. Thus, uniting love with His name is offering our self to Him, which is the principle of self-surrender (saranagati-tattva). By such self-surrender, the state of Self-abidance is attained.

41

78. Our Sadguru, Lord Ramana, who is the real Self, has given us only two paths to follow, namely Self-inquiry and self-surrender. Knowing that japa is also thus of two kinds, adhere to whichever one suits you and thereby attain Self-abidance. 

/....

bhakti and dnyana


79. To the extent to which love for God arises in one’s heart, to that extent will one acquire knowledge about Him. 

And to the extent to which one knows the nature of God, to that extent will the mind gain steadfast love for Him.

 Thus, knowledge (jnana) will be increased by devotion (bhakti), and devotion (bhakti) will be increased by knowledge (jnana). 

 80. By means of our love for God, He will give us more knowledge of Him, and by means of our knowledge of Him, He will give us more love for Him. Therefore, of these two paths, bhakti and jnana, follow that one for which you first gain a liking, because that one path will lead you to follow the other one into the heart

82. The state of abiding firmly in Self-alone is wisdom (jnana). 

Would it be possible to abide thus in Self if one did not have love for Self? 

Love for Self-alone is bhakti; 

abiding firmly in Self on account of that love alone is jnana. 

What difference is there between these two? 

Discriminate and know this truth. (Maharshi’s Gospel p.24) 


86. According to the strength of habit continuing from former lives, in this life the mind will acquire a liking either for the path of devotion or the direct and unfailing path of Self-inquiry, and will feel that particular path to be the best and most suited to itself. Therefore, follow at least one of these two paths to its very end.

............

20. Enquiry easier due to devotion

 87. When, having wept and wept with intense yearning for a long time, unceasingly thinking of and adoring the Gracious Feet (of the Lord), the mind which rises (as “I am so-and-so”) dissolves and becomes pure, 

the blemishless Self-inquiry (jnanatmavichara) will become firmly settled (in the heart) and the experience of Self (swarupa-anubhava) will of its own accord arise very easily indeed. 

– Sri Muruganar


88. O, you who say, “We have never seen you closing your eyes and practicing Self-abidance (nishtha); tell us, how did you attain the state of inner silence (mauna)?” Understanding the above verse, know the secret of (how to attain the true experience of) God, who is not seen even though one waits closing one's eyes (for a long time in expectation of seeing His true vision)

Note: the previous verse is the answer to the above question

44 

21. Self-Surrender and Self-Inquiry 

89. Since the ego itself is everything,  giving up the ego, the feeling “I am this body,” by surrendering it to God, is lovingly surrendering everything to Him. 

Having once surrendered the ego to God, 

abiding in Self,

 without taking it back again,

 (that is, without again identifying the body as “I” or “mine”)

 is true tapas.  

91. Destroying the ego through Self-attention is alone the excellent path of self-surrender.

 Therefore, scrutinizing and knowing one’s own Self is alone the proper method of practicing both self-surrender, the path of devotion, and Self-inquiry, the path of knowledge.

 Note: Compare with Who am I?; thirteenth paragraph, where Sri Bhagavan says, “Remaining firmly….surrendering oneself to God.” 

92. The path of knowledge, in which we scrutinize “Who am I?”, is itself the path of devotion in

which we have true love for God. Knowing thus, that Self-inquiry and self-surrender are one and the same, not only in their goal but also in their method of practice, follow the practice of Self-attention. 

Note: In one of His stray verses, Garland of Guru’s Sayings (or Guru Vachaka Kovai) verse B13, Sri Bhagavan says,

 “Attention to Self is supreme devotion to God, because God exists as Self.” 

..

Verse 12 ulladu narpadu

12. True knowledge is that state in which there is neither knowledge nor ignorance. Knowledge of outside objects is only ignorance. How can it be knowledge? Because the Real Self shines as the sole Reality, without any other to know It, or to be known by It, that Self is right knowledge; it is not a void.

..........

48

105. Until the root-tendency (mula-vasana) to identify a body as “I” ceases to exist, the appearances of the waking and dream states that arise due to delusion (maya) will not come to an end.

 If you, with a one-pointed mind keenly and incessantly attend to the consciousness of your existence, which shines as pure “I am,” the root-tendency “I am the body,” and all its products and other tendencies, will cease to exist. 


116. Similarly, even before all the accumulated sanchita karmas have been exhausted by being experienced in the form of prarabdha, if in this present life, which was started by prarabdha, the mind either gains firm dispassion (vairagya), being unable to bear the severe sufferings of life, or experiences intense fear of death, 

it will turn Selfwards and merge in the heart; whereupon the true awakening of Self knowledge will result. 


117. When such intense fear or suffering are experienced, if the mind with mature discrimination (viveka) at once earnestly scrutinizes, “To whom does this fear or suffering arise?” then the extroverted power of attention, which was till then being dragged out towards objects other than itself, will turn inwards to face itself, whereupon the truly awakened life of Self-abidance will immediately be attained. 

119. As soon as the inwardly awakened state of Self-abidance is attained, all the adjuncts in the form of the wrong identification that the actions of the body are one’s own actions will become devoid of reality, 

being found to be mere superimpositions upon one’s nameless and formless nature,

 just like the blue color superimposed upon the colorless sky; 

and the truth, that one is only the adjunct-free Self, will clearly shine forth. 


120. Only in this real waking state of Self abidance will true knowledge blossom in the form of the ajata experience, 

“No mundane dual activity such as birth and death has ever touched me; I am Self, the existence-consciousness which is ever devoid of the body and the senses.”


121. The pure consciousness “I,” which exists in sleep devoid of all adjuncts, is the Supreme Reality (Brahman). If we do not slip down from that state of pure consciousness due to attachment to the body (dehabhimana), that itself is the Supreme Abode (parandhama).

 If we remain, without leaving Self, that itself is liberation.


128. Except the knowledge of the first person singular, the existence “I am,” all the multifarious knowledge which shine in the waking state, and which pertain to names and forms, are only knowledge belonging to the unreal ego. 

But the knowledge of one’s own existence “I am,” is the property of Self. 


143. Having understood, “If death is only the destruction of the body, then it is merely the state in which I, the soul, am separated from the insentient body,” the mind of the aspirant will come to a bold determination, accepting thus, “Let me remain in the same manner as I would be when death occurs in practice.” 


144. This bold determination is vairagya.

 Only when it arises will true renunciation be attained. 

When true renunciation is thus attained as a result of the fear of death, then and there the divine Grace of the Guru will arise and function so as to separate us as 'other than this body' – as Self, the nature of existence-consciousness (sat-chitswarupa). 

Thus, the attachment to the body as “I” (dehabhimana) will perish.  


145. When the power of divine Grace functions thus, the true light of Self-consciousness, the one peerless reality, will shine forth, expanding and blossoming in the heart, 

whereupon in front of that brilliant light this world and our life as an individual in this world will disappear, 

being found to be a mere false appearance, just as in front of the sun, the yellow stain of turmeric disappears from a white cloth.


 146. Since the truth, “The death which comes is only for this filthy body, and is not in any way for us,” will thus shine forth as one’s own experience, the fear of death will thereafter never rise again


147. Then patient forbearance (udasina) or indifference to mundane happenings, 

absence of all base qualities, fearlessness, the steadfast power of true love, and all the six exalted divine qualities (bhagavat-gunas) divine splendor, valor, glory, pure knowledge, divine prosperity and desirelessness, will shine in one clearly and harmoniously. 


148. After the death of the mind has thus been firmly attained as a result of the fear of the death of the body, since there is no law that the body should die as soon as the mind dies, in the outlook of others the body of the Jivanmukta will continue to live, yet his mind will have died due to the dawn of true knowledge. 


149. The existence-consciousness “I am,” which continues to live even after the mind has died, alone is the Supreme Reality (Brahman), 

which continues to exist even after the entire universe has been destroyed (pralaya).

 Since there is never even for a moment any such thing as death or destruction for this Self-consciousness “I am”,

 know that this “I am” alone, is the unending and indestructible supreme Self. 


59

27. Birthlessness and Deathlessness 

150. Not thinking the body to be “I” is birthlessness; 

never forgetting the Self-consciousness “I am” is deathlessness. 

When and why will birth or death come to those who, abiding in the state of Self knowledge, are ever devoid of thinking and forgetting? 


151. Thinking of anything other than “I” is alone birth;

 not thinking of anything other than “I” is liberation (mukti). 

Will those who have learnt well the art of not thinking, and who thereby abide firmly in the thought-free state, come again under the sway of thought? 

The practice of refraining from seeing oneself as the many objects of this world is alone perfect practice (sadhana). 

If one achieves success in this sadhana, then there will be no more birth or death. 


152. In order not to experience either birth or death, let us arrive at the exalted practice (sadhana) of abiding in the natural state, which is devoid of thinking and forgetting.

 If we learn correctly how to abide thus, then for what reason will we take birth or die? 

The art of abiding without doubt in the state of Self is alone worthy for us to learn.  


28. The Transcendent Nature of Self 

153. This vast world, God, souls, bondage and liberation all appear to exist only in the waking and dream states, in which thoughts exist; but do they exist in sleep, which is devoid of thoughts?

 Similarly, they do not exist in the state of Self-knowledge (turiya). 

If one scrutinizes, “To whom do they appear to exist in waking and dream?” they will cease to exist. 


154. Since they are known only when thoughts exist, and since they do not shine when one abides firmly in Self, 

the creator of the soul, God and world is only the mind, which is the aggregate of all thoughts. 

Is this creation a work done by Self?

 No.  


29. Pramada ....( cause of world creation...sansara)

156. Know that the world, soul and God have all seemingly come into existence only because of our pramada or slackness in Self-attention. 


165. This true knowledge is not anything other than oneself;

 it is our own existence-consciousness “I am.” 

Why should we suffer by imagining and seeing the soul, world and God in this knowledge? 

Abiding firmly as mere Being, experience this knowledge correctly; then what thing other than oneself will appear there?


170. If one has the ability to deny oneself

 and thereby to destroy the rising of the ego in its very source, 

what other tapas need one perform? 


The real Self, 

the source in which the ego thus subsides and dies, 

alone is the state which is worth to purchase and attain by selling (or renouncing) all the three worlds.


173. If you first attend to yourself, by investigating within yourself 

“To whom has this illusory appearance of the world (maya) come? To whom does it exist?” 

then in the mind that has merged in the state of Silence due to such Self-attention, the truth that you exist as the mere consciousness “I am,” devoid of any differentiation, diversity or imagination (vikalpa), will spontaneously reveal itself to you. 


174. When the truth is known that you, the person who identifies the body as “I,” and who raises doubts and asks questions about phenomenal existence (maya), do not exist even in the least, then you will know as a matter of direct experience that in no place,

 at no time and in no way did phenomenal existence (maya) ever come or exist,

 and that the existence of the illusory world (maya) cannot be accepted even as a false appearance.  


182. Whatever doubt may rise, it cannot rise without you, the one who rose first and who then only raised it.

 Therefore, the original doubt, namely that of not knowing who this “you” is, is alone the root of all doubts. 


183. Until this first doubt “Who am I?” is cleared, giving replies to the other doubts raised by you, would be just like plucking the leaves that grow on the branches of a tree, because they will sprout again and again.

 If you cut the root of the tree, they will not sprout again. (Similarly, if you root out the ego by scrutinizing “Who am I?” no doubt will arise thereafter).  


184. Doubts arise about the reality of the world and God only because of one’s error of not knowing the reality of oneself. 

When one’s own reality shines as Self, the real “I” that is devoid of any other thing, what doubt can rise? 

69

35. The Learning That Should be Learnt 


189. One’s learning to abide as the indestructible existence-consciousness “I am,” 

having known it to be different from the existence of the body, 

is alone true learning,


 (the supreme science or paravidya). 


Abiding thus, having clearly known this existence-consciousness, and having thereby subsided in Self, is alone the state of true knowledge (jnana). 


190. Even though one’s mouth is dumb, (that may be an obstacle to one’s speaking but) how can that dumbness of mouth be an obstacle to one’s eating and filling one’s stomach? Similarly, even though one has not at all studied and learnt the scriptures, (that may be an obstacle to one’s delivering long and learned lectures, but it cannot be an obstacle to one’s enjoying the true happiness of Self, because) to abide permanently in Self is easy. 


192. All the knowledge which one learns (by studying countless scriptures) is nothing but a great store of thoughts and tendencies (vasanas). 

The pure (adjunctless and contentless) knowledge “I am”, which remains as Silence when one has completely discarded all those thoughts and tendencies (vasanas), is alone true knowledge (mey-jnana).

 Therefore, know that all one’s learning more and more is only ignorance (ajnana).


194. Know that making effort to achieve an inward-facing attention, which will increase the clarity of Self-awareness, 

(instead of driving the mind outwards with great force in order to acquire the useless learning (of mundane knowledge or aparavidya), which will cloud and destroy that clarity,)

 is the truest and highest learning (para-vidya). 


36. The Destruction of Our Rising 


195. Seeing the world, which appears only due to our error of not knowing that the rising “I” or ego is unreal, and thinking the world to be a very great and attractive thing,

 the persistently mischievous mind runs after it with great desire,

 hoping to enjoy all the seeming pleasures which it sees in it. 

But instead of running thus after the world, 

if the mind turns its attention towards itself 

in order to scrutinize and know the truth of the rising ego,

 it will subside with great love and will thus become one with God, who is the real Self.  

R: Not kowing the source of the rising I, M looks for pleasures outside.

Ones it knows the source of the rising I, it melts in pleasure. becomes one with God.


197. If the mind, having subsided and becoming one with Self, clearly knows that Being (as it really is) is alone real happiness, and that rising as “I” (a separate individual or ego) is nothing but misery, it will gain the fondness to subside in Self without ever rising again, having completely destroyed the duality of likes and dislikes.



37. Spiritual Maturity (Pakva) 

198. The mind will not be willing to come and follow the spiritual path until it has been repeatedly stung and afflicted by the miseries, which lie hidden like poisonous honeybees in all the worldly pleasures that are sought and attained through the five senses; and until it has thereby gained desirelessness (vairagya) towards all such pleasures.

 This alone is the reason why God gives all the sense pleasures that people ask Him to bestow, and is also the reason why the Vedas mainly recommend the path of kamya karmas (actions performed for the fulfillment of temporal desires). 

Note: When God bestows worldly pleasure upon those people who pray for them, and when the Vedas recommend people to follow the path of kamya karmas, their inner aim is only to create desirelessness or vairagya in the hearts of people by making them experience all the miseries which will inevitably accompany the enjoyment of sense-pleasures. 

Compare verse 681 of Garland of Guru Sayings, in which Sri Bhagavan says, 

“The injunction ‘Marry a girl’ is (given in the Vedas) in order to make one give up the desire for that petty pleasure (of sexual enjoyment), is it not?

 (Similarly) the injunctions which extol (the performance of) ritual sacrifices are (given) by the words of the Vedas in order to make one gain aversion for all the pleasures of heaven and so on; say, is it not so?” 


199. For people whose madness of desire for the pleasures of this world has not yet subsided, who have not become disgusted with all the efforts they have been making to obtain those pleasures,  

and whose minds have not therefore completely withdrawn from all such extroverted desires and efforts, it will not be easy to inquire, “Who am I?”, and to know the true state of Self,

 just as a reflection of one’s face will not be formed clearly in swiftly running water. 

Know that a reflection can be seen clearly only when the water stops running and collects itself calmly together in one place. 

Note: Compare Vichara Sangraham, ch. 8, paragraph 3, where Sri Bhagavan says,

 “Just as it is impossible to separate the threads of a fine silk cloth with a very gross (and blunt) crow-bar, and just as it is impossible to determine the nature of very subtle objects with a lamp which is very much wavering due to the wind, 

so it is impossible to experience the reality with a mind which, being under the sway of inertia and activity (tamo- and rajo-gunas) and thus is gross and wavering, because the reality is extremely subtle and motionless”.

200. If the liking to attain true knowledge really rises with one, 

it will be easy for one to experience Self-knowledge, the state of perfect emancipation, as clearly as an amalaka (crystal, or goose berry) fruit in the hand. 

But so long as even an iota of the liking to enjoy the pleasures of this unreal world remains unsubsided in one’s heart, the real thirst to know Self will not rise within one. 

201. To the extent in which the conviction grows stronger in us that all the extroverted activity of the mind is only misery, to that extent the desire and love to turn within will also increase. 

And to the extent to which the strength to attend to Self alone increases in us, to that extent the conviction will grow  

that attending to anything other than Self is useless. 

Thus, each one of these two (namely vairagya or desirelessness towards external objects and bhakti or the love to attend to Self) is an aid to increase the other. 

 who is a pakkva?

202. Know that he who likes to remain steadfastly attending to Self, 

knowing that Self-attention is far more important than any action that he has to do,

 than any word that he has to speak, or than any thought that he has to think, 

alone is a true mature spiritual aspirant (pakvi). 


203. Though many crores (millions) of very important thoughts rise in one’s heart, bliss can be enjoyed only when one rejects all of them and remains still, knowing that to be still is far more important than to continue attending to any thought whatsoever. 

Only by those earnest aspirants who have clearly understood this truth, can real austere practice (tapas) be possible


38. Intense Earnestness is Required



204. Just as a pearl-diver ties a stone to his waist, dives and takes the fine pearl lying in the depths of the ocean, one should fasten upon the mind a stone girdle of firm desirelessness (vairagya) and dive within oneself to take the ancient pearl of Self, the original consciousness. 

205. If a pearl-diver remains on the shore of the ocean waiting for the roaring waves to subside, will he ever succeed in gathering pearls?

 If he plunges through the waves on the surface and dives deep into the ocean with a heavy stone tied to his waist, 

what waves will he find there in the depths? 

(Similarly, if we steadfastly dive beneath the waves of thoughts into the depths of our heart, by keenly attending to the consciousness “I”, we will find that there are no thoughts there to disturb us). 

206. Since a life of great peace exists deep within the ocean of our heart, we should be completely indifferent towards the many tendencies (vasanas) which are tossing like heavy waves on the surface of that ocean, and with intense desirelessness (vairagya) we should dive deep into Self, the primal consciousness of our existence.


207. Having dived deep into the heart, which is the consciousness “I”, and having thereby rectified all kinds of sense-knowledge, which are distortions of the one real consciousness, and which rise like bubbles on the surface of the ocean, we should abide only as this existence-consciousness, 

which shines as “I am”, without knowing anything through the senses.  

r: ecb shines as I


208. When we thus abide more and more in the natural state of Self, all the innumerable tendencies (vasanas) will be destroyed. 

Other than this practice of Self-abidance, there is no effective means that will destroy the tendencies so easily and so quickly.


209. Even before all the tendencies have been completely destroyed, by one’s own desirelessness (vairagya) and by the Grace of God, it is possible for one to attain the blemishless light of Self-knowledge. 

Then by the power and clarity of that Self knowledge, the delusion of attachment to the body and mind will automatically be destroyed.

r: first self realn...then bc will go. not the other way around.


210. Those aspirants who have attained purity of mind due to the strength of the good qualities that they have gradually cultivated, and acquired through so many births, will easily learn how to abide in this state of Self-knowledge as soon as they come into the presence of the Sadguru who has manifested Himself in human form. 

r: a pakkva will know instantaneously how to abide in the self, as soon as he comes in contact with a self realized soul.


211. Do not fear. By the great power of the Grace of the Guru, who has transcended everything, you will certainly attain this Self-knowledge. If even a single tendency (vasana) remains in us, our Jnana-Guru, Lord Ramana, will not keep quiet. 

r: Guru will uproot all vasanas completely.Don't worry.

212 is horribly worded.

re-worded:

People have succeeded in achieving this state of Self Abidance.

Similarly, we could succeed by making the same effort.


 213. Other than knowing the ever-existing Self, all the aims and paths that the deceptive mind shows to be so lofty, are not worthy to be accepted even in the least by real aspirants,

 but are only worthy to be rejected. Therefore, without any fear or hesitation, reject all of them.


 214. We should not give even the least room in our heart to the demonic ghost of forgetfulness (pramada), which deludes the mind by diverting it from Self-attention. Instead, with unhesitating and irresistible courage, we should victoriously attain Self-knowledge.



39. The Thoughts That Arise During Meditation 

215. Among a collection of many kinds of small seeds, it is impossible to detect and remove the thorn-seeds. Only after all the seeds have sprouted in the form of plants is it possible to detect the thorn plants, and thereby to pluck them out and throw them away. Similarly, only if all the tendencies or vasanas which are hiding in the heart sprout out in the form of thoughts during the time of your meditation, will it be possible to destroy them by the practice of Self-inquiry. Hence, the rising of thoughts during the time of meditation is good. 

Note: Compare Maharshi's Gospel, Page 19, where Sri Bhagavan says, “Yes, all kinds of thoughts arise in meditation. That is only right; for what lies hidden in you is brought out. Unless it rises up, how can it be destroyed?” 

r ; that what manifests can easily be squashed. 


216. The tendencies (vasanas) are the seeds, and the thoughts that rise are the plants. The Grace of God or Guru is the water that makes the vasanas sprout in the form of thoughts. 

Then in order to destroy those thoughts, which exist in the form of desires, that same Grace crushes them by the power of the clear discrimination that it bestows upon us. 

Therefore, until you achieve victory in this war of Grace, do not become disheartened and give up your meditation.


78 

222. So long as any one of the three bodies is identified as “I,” it will be impossible to put an end to all the tendencies or vasanas, which are the seed-forms of thoughts. Know that in order to put an end to all tendencies, any kind of effort other than the elevated practice (sadhana) of turning and attending to Self will be of no avail.


41. Intermittent Attempts 

223. The state in which our power of attention, which now sees the objects that exist in front of our eyes, sees its own existence “I am”,

 having suddenly become introverted by giving up all objective attention and turning towards “I,” 

is alone the state of true austerity (tapas) or yoga. 

If our power of attention is used in any other way, that is only an objective attention that is opposed to true tapas or yoga

R: ahamsphurana = I

objective attention...doesn't lead to self -knowledge 

not with which I see. but by which I see. 

settle there. be with that I. 

That is tapa. that is yoga. That is dnyan. 

Anything else is not tapa, yoga or abhyas-dnyan



227. When the mind, our power of attention, having little by little gained the strength to turn Self wards, finally at one time reaches the heart due to the intensity and clarity of its Self-attention, 

it will drown in Self, 

having been caught in the clutch of the Grace of God.


 who has ever been waiting without the least forgetfulness to catch it, 

and hence it will never again turn outwards to know objects other than “I”.

R; however, this inward attention is not achieved without consistent, prolonged effort. 

Once it does, M dissolves in Self.



228. Knowing that this is indeed the peerless divine marriage of Grace, the power of attention will become settled and will attain firm abidance in Self.

 To remain steadily established in Self-abidance, being firmly bound by Self in Self, having known oneself to be that Self, is alone the state of supreme bliss.

R: Then the clarity dawns 'I am that"


  238. If the mind practices any one thing incessantly, it will naturally gain one-pointedness in that one thing.

 However, rather than any external object, the first person consciousness “I” is alone the most worthy thing for the mind to have as the target of its attention, is it not?

 By taking any second person object, such as the movement of the breath, or the right side of the chest, as the target of its attention,

the mind will attain only a state of temporary absorption in that object.

R:Focus on I-I ..first person

2nd , 3rd person avoid..temporary



 85

239. The state in which the mind, by the strength of practice (abhyasa-bala), abides or immerses itself in the attention to any second person object, however exalted that object may be, is only a state of temporary absorption of the mind (manolaya).

 On the other hand, by abiding in the state of Self-attention, the natural state of true awakening, the state of destruction of the mind (mano-nasa) will be attained. 

Since this natural state of Self knowledge alone is our goal, cling firmly only to this flawless practice (sadhana), or incessantly thinking “I, I”.

R: 2nd 3rd person.. temporary...manolaya..don't waste time

1st person ..manonasha.


243. Where there is a will, there is a way. That is, if a sincere liking to attain something arises in one’s heart, a path whereby one can attain it will also be found, and because of that liking one’s mind will unceasingly seek the goal until it is attained. 

Only when the liking to attain that goal does not truly arise in one’s heart, will one experience difficulty in the practice (sadhana) or means adopted to attain it. 

Know that this is the secret underlying all methods of practice.


87

46. Gaining One-Pointedness in Self 

246. For whatever thing a liking or love arises in you, upon that thing your mind will certainly gain one-pointedness, because such is the nature of the mind. 

Unless a real love for Self arises in you, you will not turn within and attend to it one-pointedly; 

instead you will always be telling some excuse or other for not doing so.


247. When will a real love for Self arise in you? 

Whatever your intellect decides to be the greatest and most worthy thing, for that thing alone will a love arise in you. 

The intellect of a mature spiritual aspirant will decide that Self-alone is the greatest and most worthy thing, and hence he will have real love for Self. 

But to the intellects of immature people, the objects of this world alone will appear to be great and worthy to be attained, and hence their desire for those objects will constantly be increasing.


248. When will the intellect decide that Self alone is the greatest thing? 

The intellect will esteem something as the greatest according to its decision as to what is eternal and what is ephemeral. 

What can be correctly decided by the intellect to be eternal? 

Only that thing, which can be decided to be real, is unquestionably eternal; other things are only ephemeral objects that are fit to be discarded. 


249. How to decide what is real?

 Whatever exists always and unceasingly, whatever exists without ever undergoing any change, and whatever shines by its own light of consciousness without depending upon the aid of any other thing, either to know it or to make it known – that alone is to be decided as real, is it not? Note: Compare Maharshi’s Gospel, 8th ed., page 63, where Sri Bhagavan says, “What is the standard of reality? That alone is real which exists by itself, which reveals itself by itself, and which is eternal and unchanging.”

 257. Therefore, knowing that you, the Self, alone are real, drown in your own non-dual blissful existence-consciousness and experience the state of Self-abidance, which is completely devoid of the unreal body and mind. To experience this state is alone the real duty of all good and cultured people.

259. Those people who have a clear and unshakeable understanding of their own reality, having thus discriminated and concluded that Self, the existence-consciousness “I am,” alone is real and eternal, will gain unlimited love to abide as Self and will thus attain the state of one-pointed Self-attention. 

260. When you attain the non-dual state of Self-abidance, by gaining such one-pointedness and such unequaled love for Self, you will experience the state of true spiritual discipline (tapas) in which you alone blissfully exist as the direct knowledge of Self.  

90

 47. To Heed While in Inquiry 


261. Being worried on seeing that sleep is brought about during the practice of Self-inquiry, do not give up Self-inquiry. This sleep is one among

the experiences that will arise during the initial stages of Self-inquiry. Have no doubt about this. 

262. If sleep comes, sleep well. After sleeping thus, as soon as you wake up, fix your attention with earnest love upon the self-consciousness “I am.” When the mind again subsides in that sleep-like state, and when waking returns once again, try gradually to experience the one existence consciousness that shines in between these two states. 

263. When you practice abiding more and more in the experience of this existence-consciousness, which shines between sleep and waking, the sleep that formerly appeared to overcome you will be dispersed, and the waking state in which you identify with the body and cognize external objects will not arise and engulf you again. Therefore, abide in this existence-consciousness repeatedly and untiringly. 


264. Since there is the consciousness “I am,” this state is not sleep. 

Since there is a complete absence of thoughts, this state is not waking.

 It is the state of existence-consciousness, or sat-chit, which is the undivided nature of God, or akhanda-sivaswarupa. 

Therefore, unceasingly abide in this state with great love. 


265. Why is it said, “Abide in this existence consciousness repeatedly” and “Abide in this state with great love?” Because until all the tendencies (vasanas) which drive us out of this state have ceased to exist, this state will seem to come and go. 

Therefore, until those vasanas have been completely destroyed, it is necessary to have love and to make repeated efforts to abide in this state. 

Note: Just as the moving of clouds creates the illusion that the moon itself is moving in the opposite direction, the coming and going of the mind’s tendencies (vasanas) creates the illusion that our natural state of existence-consciousness is often coming and going of its own accord. 


266. When by this practice of abiding in the state of existence-consciousness, this existence-consciousness is always experienced to be effortless and inescapably natural, then no harm will result even if sleep, dream and waking appear to come and go. 


267. For those who firmly abide in the unending state of Self-consciousness, which pervades and transcends the three states of waking, dream and sleep, that state of existence-consciousness is the only real state.

 It is the unlimited Whole (or purna). That state, in which even the feeling “I am making effort to abide” does not at all rise, alone is your natural state of Being. Be thus.

92

48. The Manner of the Dawn of Knowledge (Janodaya Vidham) 

268. Death happens in a split second. Awakening from sleep happens in a split second. Similarly, the destruction of the delusion of individuality happens in just a split second.

 True knowledge is not something that can be gained and then lost. 

If a person feels that true knowledge is coming and going, he is still only in the state of practice (or ab-hyasa). 

It cannot be said that such a person has attained true Self-knowledge. 

The perfect awakening into the state of Self-knowledge happens in just a split second. That state is not attained gradually over a long period of time. 

All the sadhanas that are practiced over a period of many years are meant only for attaining blemishless maturity. 

Listen to an apt illustration. After people have placed gunpowder in the iron barrel of a temple-cannon, after they have added broken pieces of brick, after they have packed it tight with a ramrod, after they have placed a wick in contact with the powder, and after they have plastered the open end of the barrel with clay, as soon as the charge is ignited it will explode in a split second with a blast that sounds like thunder. 

Similarly, after one has learnt the truth about the real Self through hearing and reading, after one has practiced sadhana for a long time, 

after one has wept and prayed with heart-melting devotion, and after one has thereby attained purity of mind,

the knowledge of the reality will instantaneously shine forth in a split second as “I am I”. 

As soon as the dawn of Self-knowledge thus takes place, due to the clear shining of the reality of this state, which is an

  empty space devoid of objective knowledge

will be spontaneously realized to be the state of true knowledge, which is our beginningless real nature.

When even the effort of attending to Self thereby merges in Silence, that state of mere Being, in which there is nothing further to do and nothing further to attain at any time, alone is the real state. 

Note: Refer to Sri Ramana Gita 17.5 and 17.3

..

49. Self-Knowledge 

269. One’s lying, having forgotten one’s existence consciousness, “I am,” and having drooped, is sleep. One’s being confused, mistaking one’s existence-consciousness, “I am,” to be the alien feeling “I am this body,” is dream; which is of two kinds, known as the waking state and the dream state.

 One’s experiencing one’s existence-consciousness, “I am,” without any forgetfulness (pramada), is the true waking. The former two are unreal, the latter alone is real.


270. One’s lying, having forgotten one’s existence-consciousness, “I am,” and having drooped, is the world. One’s being confused, “I am this body,” is the soul. One’s experiencing one’s existence-consciousness, “I am,” without any forgetfulness, is God. The former two are unreal, the latter alone is real. 

Note: In Vedanta, nature (prakriti) consists of three essential modes or qualities called gunas. These are sattva-guna, rajo-guna and tamo-guna respectively. Sattva, the seed or quality of intelligence, purity and equilibrium, conserves and elevates the workings of energy; rajas, the seed or quality of force or action, creates or activates the workings of energy; tamas, the seed of inertia and non-intelligence, and the denial of sattva and rajas, limits, immobilizes, impedes, deactivates or dissolves what the former two create and conserve.


  271. One’s lying, having forgotten one’s existence-consciousness, “I am,” and having drooped, is tamo-guna. One’s being confused, mistaking one’s existence-consciousness, “I am,” to be the alien feeling “I am this body,” is rajo-guna. The power of clear discernment (sphurana-sakti), which experiences one’s existence-consciousness, “I am,” is sattva-guna. Such is the nature of our illusion (maya); (that is, the concealing of our true nature by the former two gunas is ignorance or deception (avidya-maya), while the revealing of our true nature by the latter guna is true knowledge (vidya-maya).


272. Even when one drooped (as in sleep), having forgotten oneself, the consciousness “I am” was nonetheless existing and shining. Even when one was confused, mistaking oneself to be the body (as in waking and dream), the consciousness “I am” was still existing and shining (as the base and support of the perverted consciousness “I am the body”). Therefore, when I thus exist and know myself as the one who existed and shone (in the above two states), what obstacle can ever arise to impede me from existing and knowing my existence? 


273. Therefore, one’s lying, having forgotten one’s existence-consciousness, “I am,” and having drooped, is not (something which ever truly happened). 

One’s being confused, mistaking one’s existence-consciousness, “I am,” to be the alien feeling “I am the body,” is not (something which ever truly happened). 

One’s newly experiencing one’s existence-consciousness, “I am,” is not (something which ever truly happens). 

Such is the nature of the experience of true knowledge (jnana).


 274. Only so long as it falsely appears as if we have forgotten our existence-consciousness, “I am,” can an effort arise as an effort (tapas) or practice (sadhana) to know and attain Self. 

After we have clearly known that we have never forgotten Self, and that the feeling as if we have forgotten Self is a mere imagination (kalpana), there will be no practice (sadhana) for us to do. The truth is that we ever exist only as mere Being.


275. To think that we have at some time lost or forgotten yourself is not true. If on the contrary it were true, then even if we were to make effort and attain Self, we may again lose it. Then what to do? 


276. This true state of Self is not a state that can undergo changes, such as being lost, or again being attained. Know that this state is that which is never lost. In front of the clear light of the sun of Self knowledge, which is devoid of changes such as being lost or being attained, how can such changes, which are an unreal darkness, take place?


277. This existing reality is not something that can be reached and attained like an object other than “I.” All that is to be done is only to abide as it is, having set aside the empty imagination that has risen within us that we have lost that state. 

Setting aside that imagination is to abide in Self. 

Having turned our attention within. 

Withdrawing it from all other objects. 

The true state is nothing other than this.

..

50. Untouching Union (A sparsha Yoga) 

278. Our existence and the consciousness of our existence ever remain unseparated from us; when it is so, why should the state in which we remain as we are be called a state of yoga, in which we have approached and united (with our own existence)? We are always only one; therefore, the natural state in which we abide as we are, is not a state of our uniting with ourself, nor is it a state of our becoming ourself. Declare that that state is the state of “not touching” (asparsam); that is, the state of separation from all adjuncts such as the body and mind).

 

97

279. To talk in admiration about going and uniting hereafter with our natural state, which is non dual and which can never become two, and to glorify that this is yoga, is appropriate only for people who are deluded into believing that their ego-life (which is experienced only in the darkness of ignorance) is the real life. 

Know clearly that the truth is that no yoga is necessary for our real nature.  

Translator’s note: The above two verses were written to explain the significance of the term asparsa yoga, which literally means “untouching union,” and which is used in certain Vedantic texts such as the Mandukya Karikas (3.39 and 4.2). To unite with something, one must touch it; but since we have never been separated from the reality, which is our own true nature, how are we either to touch it or to unite with it? Therefore, if the natural state in which we abide as Self, is to be called a state of “union” or “yoga”, it is only an “untouching union” or “asparsa yoga”; that is, a state of oneness which is not brought about afresh by any act of union, but which is realized to be the ever-existing nondual state of existence-consciousness from which we have never been separated.

51. Who is a Jnani? 


280. Is the intellect, which decides, “This person is a Jnani; that person is an ajnani” knowledge (jnana) or ignorance (ajnana)? 

Jnana is only one! Therefore, even the Jnani who is seen by the mind, the ajnana that sees Jnanis as many, is only a product of that ajnana. 


281. You (the mind that sees others) are yourself a mere thought. Therefore, the person who is said by you to be a pure soul, or a Mahatma, is only one among the many thoughts that are thought by you, the first thought! How can such a thought, which is an illusory product of ajnana, be a supreme Knower of Self (Atma-jnani)? Reflecting in this manner, know this truth. 


 282. To say, “He is a good soul, a Jnani, I know,” is untrue. Even to say, “All people are Jnanis,” is untrue, because to see as if many people are existing, is the sign of ignorance. Only one person truly exists; that is you. Know thus. 


283. In the true outlook of the Jnani, there is no ajnani (because there is no one who is other than himself). The ajnani (pointing to a body and saying “This person is a Jnani,” gives the name “Jnani” only to a body. Due to this defective outlook, where-by the ajnani sees even the Jnani as a body, he becomes one who sees even the Jnani only as an ajnani.


 284. Even though you may visit any number of Mahatmas, and even though they may exhibit all the eightfold occult powers (ashta siddhis), 

know that he who turns your attention towards Self saying, “Without allowing your mind to go after these juggleries, turn within,” is alone the true pure soul (Mahatma).


285. Let the individual (jivatma) who enters the lofty Himalayas and forests seeking Mahatmas, enter instead the heart, by turning within seeking “Where am I?” and thereby become the blissful Self (sukhatma-swarupa). 

Thereafter, all who were seen externally as pure souls (Mahatmas) will be experienced by him to be his own Self (atma-swarupa). This is the teaching given by Sri Ramana Bhagavan. 


286. Before one knows oneself, in whatever way one may try, it is not possible for one to know the real tapasvis (the Jnanis, who ever remain in the egoless state of Self-abidance, the true state of tapas). Therefore, giving up all the futile efforts to seek externally to know pure souls (Mahatmas), cling firmly to the great and worthwhile effort of attending to Self, which will destroy the unreal feeling “I am an individual jiva.” 

287. Therefore, if any thought arises in you hereafter to seek to determine whether someone is a Jnani or an ajnani, reject that thought immediately by inquiring “Who am I who rise to determine about the state of others?” and thus merge your mind in the heart, the source from which that thought arose, by turning within and keenly fixing your attention in that source. 

288. If you give up the effort to know whether a certain person is a Jnani or an ajnani, and instead scrutinize “Who is it who feels that this person exists?” the answer will be known “It is I.” Then scruti-

nize immediately “Who is this rising I?” The true Jnani will then shine forth (being clearly known to be your own Self, “I-I”).

289. If someone is a Jnani, what is that to us? So long as we do not know ourself, that will be of no benefit to us. On scrutiny, Jnana alone is the Jnani; the Jnani is not a human form; he is only the supreme space of pure consciousness. That supreme space is our true nature.

 290. Therefore, by Self-inquiry destroy the petty mind, which seeks to know “This person is a Jnani; that person is a Jnani.” The Jnana (the pure Self consciousness “I am” that remains after the mind has thus been destroyed), which shines as one (devoid of any other) and which does not rise and jump as “I am this” or “I am that”, is alone the Jnani. Seeing the Jnani thus by Silence (the thought-free state which remains after the mind has been destroyed) is alone seeing him correctly.  

52. The Ultimate Secret of Spiritual Practice (Sadhanottava Rahasya) 

291. (Among the three places or persons [the first, second and third persons], and among the three times, the present, past and future)

 the first person (known in Tamil as tanmai-idam or the “selfness-place”

and the present time, are the place and the time that Sadguru Sri Ramana told us to scrutinize (as our dhyana-laksha, or target for attention).

 If you abide, attending with subtle vigilance to either of these, investigating “Who is this first person, who shines as I?” or 

“What is this present time that shines as the consciousness am?“ you will experience the supreme joy of Self (atma-parabhoga) – having accomplished yoga and having become one who has attained siddhi (the state of final liberation). See and feast upon Self, thus.


////////////////////////  the end////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////




1. ELEVEN VERSES ON SELF-INQUIRY (ATMA-VICHARA PATIKAM) 


1. Thinking is a vritti; being is not a vritti (thought).

 If we scrutinize “Who is thinking?” the thinking process will come to as standstill. 

Even when thoughts do not exist, do you have any doubt about your own existence as “I am”? 

Abiding in your own existence, which shines as “I am,” the source, from which all thoughts rise, is the state of Self Abidance. 

Abide thus. 

2. He who thinks is the soul, or jiva. He who exists as “I am” without any thought is God. If the thinker thinks with great love of that which merely exists as “I am,” this Self ward-turned thought will become the thought-free consciousness, which will destroy all thoughts. 

When the thinker thus dies along with his thoughts, the state of abidance, which then remains shining as “I am,” is the state of union with God or Siva-sayujya. 

3. He who thinks, “I am so-and-so” is just a thought like all the other thoughts. But of all thoughts, this thought, “I am so-and-so” alone is the first. 

The soul who thinks, “I am so-and-so” is merely a reflection of our real Self. When we abide and shine only as that real Self, the thought “I am so-and-so” will not rise. 

4. In dreamless sleep, this thought “I am so-and so” does not at all exist. In the true state of Self-knowledge also, this thought “I am so-and-so” does not at all exist. But in the states of waking and dream, which rise in between the darkness of sleep and the pure light of Self-knowledge, the thought “I am this body” seems to appear and disappear. Therefore this limited “I” is not real; this “I” is only a thought. 

5. The flourishing of this “I” is only the flourishing of misery. This “I” is that which is called the ego.

 This ego-”I” rises and flourishes only because of non-inquiry (avichara). 

If we enquire “Who is this I?”, and thereby vigilantly scrutinize only the feeling “I,” without attending to the adjunct “so-and-so” with which it is mixed, this adjunct will disappear, since it is devoid of any real existence.

 6. The second and third persons, the known objects, subsist only because of the first person, the knowing subject, who is the root. If the mind, which is ever wavering because of attending to second and third persons, turns and attends to the first person, who rises as “I am so-and-so,” the adjunct “so and-so” will cease to exist and the real Self, which always exists as “I am,” will shine forth spontaneously

That real Self, which is the indestructible base of the first person, alone is true knowledge (Jnana). 

7. Thinking about second and third persons is foolishness, because when we attend to second and third persons the mental activities (mano-vrittis) rise up and multiply. 


But the act of attending to the first person is equal to committing suicide, because only by scrutinizing the first person will the ego die of its own accord. 


8. Attending to any second or third person instead of turning and attending to this “I,” the first person feeling that is always experienced by everyone, is only ignorance (ajnana).

 If you ask, “The ego (the feeling ‘I am so-and-so’) is only a product of ignorance, so attending to the ego is also ignorance, is it not? Why then should we attend to this ‘I’?” Listen to what is said below: 

9. Why is the ego destroyed when we scrutinize “What am I”? Because this “I”-thought (aham-vritti) is a reflected ray of Self-consciousness; and thus unlike other thoughts, which are devoid of consciousness, it is always directly connected with its source.

 Therefore, when our attention dives deeper and deeper within by following this reflected ray “I,” the length of this reflected ray “I” will diminish until finally it has shrunk to nothing. 

When the ego, the feeling “I am so-and-so,” thus disappears, the consciousness that will remain shining as “I am I” is the true knowledge of Self. 


10. Do not do anything thinking, “It should be done only by me.” Nothing is done by you, because you are simply nothing. 

Knowing this truth from the beginning, if you refrain entirely from rising as “I am the doer,” all actions will happen of their own accord, and your peace will ever remain undisturbed. 


11. If we scrutinize “What is the reality that ever exists?” we will find that nothing in this world is real.

 Since Self alone is real, let us mentally renounce everything else and ever abide unshakably as that reality, which will remain shining alone as “I am.”

 This alone is the service enjoined upon us by Lord Ramana, who ever-abides as the eternal Self.


Note: “Abiding in this state, having attained the supreme bliss which is devoid of bondage and liberation, is abiding in the service of God”, says Sri Bhagavan in verse 29 of Upadesa Undiyar.

 

................................................              ....................................................

106

2. FORTY VERSES ON RENUNCIATION (Turavu Narpadu)

8. If a wandering religious mendicant (parivrajaka sannyasi) wanders about depending entirely upon God to provide his material needs each day, without ever seeking to acquire or save anything for the morrow with the thought, “Let this place of abode or this food be available for me for another occasion,” 

his faith in God will increase. He will gain the strength to live with an attitude of complete dependence upon God alone, and not upon any people).

9. Not knowing that by this wandering (parivrajaka) life he should thus learn to develop the quality of depending only upon God for everything, ...........

12...His begging is a training, which he undergoes in order to attain a state of mind in which he can experience an equal love towards those who revile him with mean words, and those who praise him with kind words.

13. The benefit which a true renunciate (sannyasi) is to gain by living a wandering (parivrajaka) life is to attain a state of mind which is fully contented, being endowed both with an attitude of com-plete dependence upon God-alone at all times, and with a patient endurance, which cannot be shaken by either the abuse or the praise of others.

18. A person who has attained true renunciation is verily dead to this world.

 Such a true renunciate (sannyasi) is indeed superior to all the other people of this world. He is the embodiment of all virtue and ethical conduct (dharma).

 Therefore, he alone is an object worthy to be worshipped and adored by this entire world. 

22 kuti-chaka ok.

Matha-adhipati avoid

24. Hence, (when seen from the standpoint of a true aspirant who seeks only liberation) all endeavors such as establishing asramas and religious institutions are only purchasing great sufferings and difficulties for a price. To seek to establish asramas and public institutions by collecting money by going from place to place, climbing on platforms and giving lectures and discourses, is just like going and playing with a venomous snake. 

26. With the firm dispassion (vairagya) of not cherishing or hoarding anything for the morrow (having an unshakeable faith that God will provide you each day with whatever is good for you)

pass the days of accepting whatever comes to you of its own accord on each occasion without giving any work to your brain (to investigate whether each thing which comes is good or bad and to decide whether it is to be accepted or rejected).   


27. If you, who have come to this world alone, live alone (being free of attachment to anything) and subside in Self 

by knowing what is the reality of yourself

know that that is the greatest help which you can render to all the other people in this world.  


28. Going and approaching the people of the world (collecting money and engaging in many external activities) in the name of social service (paropakara seva) and desireless action (nishkamya karma) is not behavior befitting the purity of renunciation (sannyasa). 

Without a sense of doership, do whatever good action comes to you of its own accord forcibly prompting you to act, by making you feel that it is necessary to do so, and then at once forget it.


29. He who remains like a dead person in all worldly affairs without rising as “I” under any circumstances, is alone the most exalted among the sanyasis. 

He alone is a Jivanmukta (enlightened while still in the body).

 He alone is a true non-doer (a-karta) (because he has no sense of doership in whatever actions he may appear to be doing). 

Therefore, he alone is a true karma yogi (a person who does actions without any selfish motivation or desire).

30.  Quit karma after attaining purity of M

The path of karma yoga (selfless service), which is practiced by anyone other than such a Jivanmukta (see previous verse), will gradually remove the impurities from the mind, and it will stop with thus imparting complete purity of mind. After thus attaining purity of mind, it is proper that a person should give up the path of karma yoga and should follow either the path of devotion (bhakti) or the path of Self-inquiry and thereby attain the egoless state of Self. 

31.  Karma for chittashuddhi (alone )

The fruit to be attained from  karma yoga, which bestows purity of mind (chittasuddhi), 

is only to make one mature and fit to follow the paths of devotion (bhakti) or Self-inquiry (vichara). 

But unless a sanyasi is already fit to follow either of these two paths, know that he will not gain the real fruit of the renunciation (sannyasa), which he has taken. 

(no bhakti or SE if not layak)


32. For a person who has taken renunciation (sannyasa) in order to attain God, the supreme real-ity, it is not proper to go outwards seeking worldly people and climbing on platforms to give lectures. Instead of turning within towards God and becoming established in Self-abidance, if a renunciate (sannyasi) turns towards the alluring and deceptive world, diverting his mind to the habit of giving lectures, he will be doing great harm to himself.

33. You have taken this renunciation (sannyasa) not for the sake of giving spiritual instructions (upadesa) to the people of this world, but only to attain the infinite Self, and to remain firmly established in Self-abidance. Why do you forget this truth and wander about in the world giving lectures?

34. Only the real renunciate (sannyasi), who never deviates from the state of firm Self-abidance

 is a person who is correctly teaching true knowledge to all other people. 


Rather than by climbing on platforms to give lectures by mouth, if one turns the mind within away from the world and abides in Self, then the entire world, which seems to exist externally, will be awakened into the state of true knowledge. 


 35. Without sanyasa, to attain liberation is not in the least possible; but renunciation (sannyasa) truly means only inward renunciation (that is, the renunciation of the first thought “I am this body”) and not anything else (that is, not the assuming of any traditional outward guise such as ochre cloth and shaven head).


reworded- not possible to attain libn without sanyas.

sanyas means inwardness. nothing else.


37. To become devoid of all impurities in the mind is true sanyasa. If one abides in the true state of Self, which is devoid of all thoughts, that itself is all virtues and dharmas. If one attains the state of being devoid of even the desire to become a sanyasi), that itself is the true attainment of sanyas

  

Friday, 26 February 2021

Path of Ramana Part 2

 https://www.happinessofbeing.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/09/The_Path_of_Sri_Ramana_Part_Two-4.pdf

210 pgs


17 

Thus we come to understand that fate and free will are not elements contradicting each other. 

We are finally brought to the conclusion that unconditional Self-surrender in which no room is given even to any kind of prayers, is the best karma (action).

 This is nothing but Self-abidance. 

Thus Sri Sadhu Om convinces us that the best Karma (Action), the best Bhakti (Devotion) and the best Jnana (Knowledge) is nothing but abiding in the Self, Our True Nature, through Self-enquiry, proving the verses of Shri Bhagavan 

“This – permanently remaining absorbed into its source whence it had its rising – is Karma and Bhakti; this is Yoga and Jnana.” – 

Upadesha Undiyar -Verse 10. 

“The enquiry to whom is action (karma), non devotion, disunion and ignorance is itself Karma, Bhakti, Yoga and Jnana... The abidance as the Self is verily the truth”. – Ulladu Narpadhu - Anubandham - Verse 14.

.........

21 chp 1 

..


So long as a man experiences himself and the world as two separate entities, each having a distinct individual existence, he cannot in practice conceive even the mind transcending state of Parinirvana to be anything but a third which is distinct from himself and the world.


Lord Buddha declined to say anything about God in reply to those who asked about Him. But, knowing that it would serve no useful purpose to say anything not only about God but even about the world and its nature, in reply to people who asked about them Sri Bhagavan used to repeatedly insist, 

“Let us see about God and the world afterwards; first know yourself”.

 ‘The world is real’,

 ‘No, it is an unreal appearance’; 

‘The world is sentient’, ‘It is not’; ‘The world is happiness’, ‘It is not’; – what is the use of arguing thus in vain? 

Having given up (attending to) the world, having known oneself, and both one and two (thoughts about non-duality and duality) having come to an end - that state in which ‘I’ (the ego) has ceased to exist is agreeable to all. 

– Ulladu Narpadu verse 3


 Thus Sri Bhagavan teaches that the first and foremost need for us is to know ourself, the first person.

25

Do we not know about the existence of three persons, the first person, second person and third person? But have we made research on all these three persons and have we tried to find out what the nature of each one of them is? 

No, we have so far made research only upon the second and third persons, and we have failed up till now to scrutinize or make research upon the first person. 

How? See the way in which we make use of our power of attention when we wake up from sleep. As soon as we wake up, the first thing we know is our body, and then we notice the place where we are lying, the objects which surround us, the outside world and so on. 

Knowing all these things is only a second person attention. Thus when we wake up, our power of attention springs out only towards second and third person objects. 

Then, until we fall asleep again, our power of attention continues to dwell only upon the second and third persons by clinging to and experiencing the objects known through the five senses. At night, as soon as sleep overpowers us, our attention towards second and third persons ceases. 

What exactly happens to the power of attention in sleep is not correctly known to anyone except to those who have attained Self Knowledge. In this manner, from the moment of waking up till the moment of going to sleep, from birth till death, from creation till dissolution, all people - indeed all living beings -

 direct their power of attention only towards second and third person objects, and no one ever directs it towards the first person! 

This great error is what is called the ‘original sin’.

All the ancient Sages of India realised the truth in the end only by knowing the real nature of this first person

Even in the West there have occasionally been people here and there who have attained Self-Knowledge in the same way. Therefore, if any of the people who have written heaps of books on psychology have not after all their research come to the same conclusion as that which is proclaimed by Vedanta, namely that ‘I’ alone is the absolute truth, and if they have not thereby attained the true experience of Self, we will have to conclude that their research was not a scrutiny of the correct first person. All that they have done was to attend to a second person object called ‘mind’.

As we saw earlier in this book, the word ‘mind’ is generally taken to be a collective name for the whole multitude of thoughts, although in actual fact the only fundamental and essential characteristic of the mind is the root thought ‘I’, the first person singular feeling. Thus the word ‘mind’ may be said to have two meanings. Its primary meaning is the subjective aspect of the mind, namely the first person thought ‘I’, while its secondary meaning is the objective aspect of the mind, namely the multitude of other thoughts, all of which exist only by depending upon this first thought ‘I’. This multitude of thoughts is only a crowd of second person objects.

All that psychologists have made research upon is this objective aspect of the mind, and they have never made research upon its subjective aspect, the first person thought ‘I’. Since all the thoughts which form the objective aspect the mind are only second persons, any research made upon them cannot be a scrutiny of the first person. It is only a research

made upon an object (drisya) which is known by us as other than ‘I’, the knowing subject (drik). Books on psychology, parapsychology and other such sciences which relate to the nature of the mind are merely the outcome of the research which has been made upon the mysteries of this second person mind, because such sciences are concerned only with investigating and knowing the mind as an object - that is, they merely seek to know what are the various ways in which the mind can function, what are all the secret powers which lie hidden within the mind, what are the means by which such wonderful powers may be roused and developed so that they can be used as supernatural attainments (siddhis) in order to achieve one’s own selfish ends, and so on and forth. Thus even sciences like psychology turn out to be only a research made upon a second person object. Just as other scientists make research upon gross second and third person objects such as atoms, psychologists make research upon a subtle second person object called mind. And just as the results which have been achieved through other branches of scientific research are only a mixture of good and evil, so the results which have been achieved through psychological research are also only a mixture of good and evil. Therefore, since psychological research has not resulted in the blissful peace of Self-Knowledge, which transcends all such dualities as good and evil, it is clear that such research is not an attention to the correct first person object. 

Turning one’s attention towards oneself in order to find out ‘Who am I, who knows the mind?’ alone is the correct first person attention. Anyone who attends to himself in this manner, whoever he may be, will certainly attain the true Knowledge of Self.


Thus the principle teaching which He has given to the whole world is only the practice of Self-attention, which is the easy and direct path and which is so rational that is can be accepted and followed by all people.

Religion (mata) will exist only so long as the mind (mati) exists. In the abundantly peaceful great Silence in which that mind has merged in the heart by turning within scrutinizing itself (enquiring ‘who am I, this mind?’), no such religion can stand. – Guru Vachaka Kovai verse 993

The revelation or darsanam of Sri Ramana is only the absolute truth (paramarthikasatya) in which the path and the goal are found to be both one and the same. Since the eternal Self is non-dual and since there is no other path (to attain it) except (to attend to and thereby to abide as) Self, the goal to be attained is only Self and the path is only Self. Know them (the goal and the path) to be non different. – Guru Vachaka Kovai verse 579

Sri Bhagavan has shown us that it is only because man has not yet attained a correct knowledge of the first person, that it has been impossible for him to have a correct knowledge about the truth of the second and third person objects, the world and God, and that it is only because man has not yet attained a true knowledge about the second and third person objects–that is, only because man continues to have the wrong knowledge that the second and third persons are different from the truth of the first person –, that so much unnecessary confusion and strife prevails among the people of the world and that as a consequence so many misfortunes and calamities have befallen mankind. 

Being the perfect spiritual doctor that He is, Sri Bhagavan has thus clearly and precisely diagnosed the exact nature of the dangerous disease which exists in the mind of mankind. Moreover, He has also prescribed an entirely new method of treatment– namely taking the medicine of Self-attention and observing the diet-restriction of completely abstaining from attending to second and third person objects–and thereby He has provided us with the perfect remedy which will surely remove the primal disease of mankind, the disease known as ‘original sin’. 

If we scrutinize this method of treatment more deeply, we will understand that the medicine is devotion (bhakti) and the diet-restriction is desirelessness (vairagya). 

Sri Bhagavan has also clearly explained that the correct way of taking the medicine of Self-enquiry is to attend to oneself in order to find out ‘Who am I’? and He has given us many clues to facilitate this practice. All of these things He has taught us, from His own experience of Self-Knowledge, which dawned in Him all of a sudden without His having studied any books and without His having had any other person as a Guru to teach Him. Hence the sole purpose of this exposition of Sri Bhagavan’s teachings is to enable mankind to know the correct target towards which it should aim the arrow of its attention and to enable it thereby to direct its research towards the proper goal.

...After an ‘I’ rises, everything rises... - Ulladu Narpadu verse 23 

If the ego comes into existence, everything will come into existence. If the ego does not exist, everything will not exist. The ego itself is everything. - Ulladu Narpadu verse 26

 If the thought ‘I’ does not exist, no other things will exist.... – Sri Arunachala Ashtakam verse 7

39

When the mind is thus found to be ever non - existent, the world-appearance seen by it will also be found to be non-existent. Hence ajata alone is the absolute truth (paramarthika satya).

44 imp

If oneself is a form (the body), the world and God will be likewise (that is, they will also be forms); if oneself is not a form, who can see their forms, and how? Can the sight (that which is seen) be otherwise than the eye (the seer) ?... 

– Ulladu Narpadu verse 4

On account of the ego, the feeling ‘I am the body’, experiencing all the worlds, which are not other than consciousness, as if they were different from oneself, who is that consciousness, is a creation of the dense and expansive delusion (of ajnana or ignorance of one’s true nature). – Guru Vachaka Kovai verse 67.

imp

Having limited and transformed oneself into a body, and having transformed the knowledge gathered through the five senses of that body into the world, one sees that the world, which is nothing other than one’s own real Self, as objects which are other than oneself, and one is thereby deluded with likes and dislikes for those objects. Such confusion alone is what is called the world-illusion (jagat-maya). – Sadhanai Saram verse 44. 

When one always abides unswervingly in one’s own state without knowing (any differences such as) ‘oneself’ and ‘others’... who is there other than oneself? 

–Ulladu Narpadu Anubandham verse 38.

There is no becoming, no destruction, no one in bondage, no one having desire to be released, no one making effort (to attain liberation) and no one who has attained Liberation. Know that this is the absolute truth (paramartha).

 – Upadesa Tanippakkal verse 24

If we turn our power of attention towards “our own” Self, our limited sense of individuality will cease to exist, and hence the appearances of the world and God will come to an end.

We can understand this truth even from our experience in the ordinary state of sleep. When we are asleep, we do not have even the least knowledge or doubt about either the world or God. Why? Because in sleep we, the ego, the limited first person feeling ‘I am this body’, do not exist, and hence the other two entities, the world and God, do not exist. Thus merely by our creating ourself as a limited individual soul on account of our pramada or forgetfulness of Self, we simultaneously become the one who has created the other two entities, the world and God

Without ignorance (about an object), knowledge (about that object) does not exist; (similarly) without (that) knowledge, that ignorance does not exist... – Ulladu Narpadu verse 10

50

If an aspirant truly engages himself in the practice of Self-attention, he will often feel as if the state of Self-consciousness, which is his own true nature, is clearly known for some time and as if it is afterwards obscured. 

On such occasion he will be able to understand very clearly from his own experience how the world-appearance vanishes and how it again comes into existence. 

Because of the speed of forgetfulness or pramada by which he swerve from the state of Self-attention, it may be difficult in the beginning for an aspirant to notice exactly when he loses his hold on Self-attention. 

In due course, however, because of the clarity and strength which he will gain by repeatedly practicing Self-attention, it will become possible for him to notice the exact moment when Self-attention is lost, and thus it will become possible for him to regain it immediately. 

On all the occasions when he thus clearly cognizes the moment when Self-attention is lost and the moment when it is regained, the aspirant will be able to know very easily from his own experience 

how the world is created by his losing Self-attention and

 how it is then destroyed by his regaining Self-attention.

 Thus the aspirant will come to know with absolute certainty that his giving room to slackness in Self-attention is the means by which the body and world are created,

 that his maintaining slackness in Self-attention on account of his lack of interest either to notice that such slackness had occurred or to put an end to it, 

is the means by which the world is sustained, 

and that his firmly abiding once again in his own real and, blissful state of pure Consciousness, which is devoid of the limitations of name and form,

 having vigilantly known the exact moment when slackness in Self-attention occurred and having thereby put an end to it, is the means’ by which the world is destroyed. 

When the aspirant comes to know this truth from his own direct experience, he will realise himself to be the perfect Supreme Reality which transcends the three functions of creation, sustenance and destruction, and hence he will remain unshakably established in the state of absolute peace.


A person will feel no liking to take to the practice of Self-attention until he gains the proper discrimination whereby he can understand that the two states of creation and sustenance, which are merely a mixture of pleasure and pain, are not worthy to be cherished and pursued.

So long as he continues to give importance to these two states, which are nothing but mere appearances, he will be liable to build castles in the air by imagining that he can eliminate pain from this mixture of pleasure and pain, which is one of the many dyads, and that he can thereby make pleasure alone prevail in two states of creation and sustenance. Though such a person may be very broad-minded, generous-hearted and compassionate, since he may even be deluded to the extent of believing that the miseries which we now see in the world would not have existed if, the functions of creations and sustenance had been performed in accordance with his own visionary ideas, and thus he will find fault even with God, who is now performing those functions and he will wistfully imagine that he must take responsibility for carrying out a reform in the present manner in which God is governing the world. He will then proceed to draw up wonderful plans whereby he hopes to transform this world into a blissful heaven and remove all the miseries seen in it, even hoping to make the body of man immortal. 

Such a well-intentioned but deluded person will then begin to ponder how and from where he can acquire the divine power or sakti which is necessary in order for him to carry out this wonderful unselfish plan of his, and he will begin to devise and practice many new kinds of yoga in the hopes of achieving such power. 

Finally, however, he will have to come to the conclusion that he can obtain such power only from God, the almighty Supreme Lord who is at present creating and sustaining this whole world, and so he will then select the method of complete self-surrender as a means of begging and acquiring such power from Him. Being confident that the unlimited power of God will surely be showered upon him if he adopts this method, and believing that with that power he can fulfil all the wonderful plans which he has drawn up, he will be waiting in eager expectation for the day when that power will descend from above.

Knowing that there were people who were actually so deluded as to imagine, like the man described above, that it was both necessary and possible for them to bring about a radical reformation in the manner in which the world had been created and was being governed by God, Sri Bhagavan composed the following two verses : The buffonery of the madmen who, not knowing the manner in which they function by sakti (that is, not knowing the truth that it is only by the atmasakti or power of Self that they are enabled to function and perform activities), engage in activities saying, “We shall obtain all occult powers (siddhis)”, is like the story of the cripple who said, “If someone helps me to stand, what are these enemies (that is, how powerless they will be in front of me)?” See, when God is bearing the burden of the world, the pseudo soul (imagining as if it were) bearing (that burden) is a mockery like the form of a gopuram-tangi (a sculptured figure which seems to support the top of a temple 

tower with great strain, but which in fact is itself supported by the tower). Whose fault is it if someone who is travelling in a train, which is bearing a great burden, undergoes suffering by bearing (his small) burden on (his own) head instead of placing it on the train?

 – Ulladu Narpadu Anubandham verse 15 & 17


But if the man described above really takes to the path of complete self-surrender in order to acquire from God the power which is necessary for him to bring about such a radical reformation in the creation, what will actually happen in the end? If and when the surrender becomes complete, the mind or ego which had risen as ‘I am so-and-so’ and which had cherished all the wonderful notions mentioned above, will surely drown and perish in Self, the source from which it had risen, thereby losing its separate individuality. Until and unless the ego is thus annihilated, the surrender cannot be said to be complete. Since a person therefore cannot remain as a separate individual entity after he has completely surrendered himself to God, upon whom is the divine power to descend, and who is to make use of that power to reform the world? Thus in the end all the hopes and ambitions cherished by this poor man will turn out to be completely meaningless and absurd, just like the patently ficticious story told in Kaivalya Navanitam, chapter 2, verse 89. The son of a barren woman and the man seen superimposed on a post, wearing wreaths of flowers imagined in the sky, haggled about the

price of the silver in the mother-of-pearl, began to fight in the city shining in the clouds, stabbed each other with the horns of a hare, became exhausted and died, after which they both became ghosts: on hearing such a story, no wise man will be deceived. Why should any man unnecessarily tax his brain and confuse himself by cherishing such ideas and ambitions? 

When Sri Bhagavan was once asked about the beliefs of a certain philosopher who cherished the strange notions mentioned above, He briefly replied, 

Let the surrender first become complete; we can see about everything else afterwards’. 

Why did He reply in this way? 

Transforming this world into a heaven devoid of misery and making man immortal are not things which have to be newly done. Even now the world is truly nothing other than Brahman, the blissful Supreme Reality, and man is in his true nature nothing other than Self, the immortal spirit. Therefore the world and man do not n

ow need to be made either blissful or immortal. 

All that we need to do is to see them as they really are

That is why Sages say, 

“Making one’s outlook of the nature of knowledge, one should see the world as Brahman” 

drishtim jnanamayin kritva pasyet brahmamayam jagat. 

The defects which we now see in the world and in man are not defects in God’s creation but are only defects in our own outlook. Therefore there is no use in trying to rectify God’s

creation by usurping His power; if we wish to rectify all the defects which we see, we must rectify our own outlook; there is no other way. Those who know the reality will declare that there is no defect in creation (srishti), but that there is a defect only in outlook (drishti).

 – Sri Ramana Jnana Bodham, vol. 1, verse 1696.

56

60

If we realize, from what has been said above, the fact that the real cause of all the miseries that appear to us in the world is solely due to our defective outlook that has come into existence as a result of our contracting our limitless blissful Nature of existence into a limited body through the unlimited freedom inherent in us of using our Will, it will then become obvious that the only wise thing to do, is to put an end to the disease of the appearance of the world and body (through Self-attention) and be ever blissful.

64

This is explained by Sri Bhagavan Ramana in verse 17 of ‘Ulladu Narpadu’:- “For those who have not realised the Self and as well for those who have realised the Self, this body is ‘I’; but, for those who have not realised the Self, the ‘I’ is confined only to the limit of the body; and for those who have realised the Self within the body (i.e., in this very life time), the ‘I’ shines as the limitless Self. Know that this is the only difference between these two.”

Sri Bhagavan Ramana in verse 18 of ‘Ulladu Narpadu’:- 

“The world is real for those who have not realised the Self as well as for those who have realised. 

For those who have not realised, the reality is of the measure (i.e, name and form) of the world: 

For those who have realised, the reality shines as the nameless and formless substratum of the world. 

Know that this is the only difference between these two”

...But, to really experience the universe as God (which is really worshipping it) is possible only, after

realising the true nature of the Self, where the world and God will not remain as entities other than the Self. 

“In the heart at first you see Him who is everywhere; 

Only then that all exists as Him you’ll be aware.” 

- Dhyanappattu - Sadanai Saram. 

But by viewing the world and the living beings in it as God, at least by mind, a great good does result namely the purification of mind. This is the hidden aim of Karma Yoga. Karma Yoga allows a man to discriminate and decide what is good for himself and what is good for others according even to his ordinary mind and allows him to act accordingly. But it is to be known that the purpose of this allowance is neither the complete eradication of the miseries of the world nor the capturing of God, the inaccessible One.

orld nor the capturing of God, the inaccessible One. Sri Bhagavan Ramana gives out the method and the result of Karma Yoga in ‘Upadesha Undiyar’, verse 3: “Acts performed without attachment to the results and dedicated to the Lord, purify the mind and point the way to Liberation”. 

Therefore the purpose of Karma Yoga is only the purification of the mind. This purpose being the hidden aim, is enjoined in Karma Yoga. 

“You have the right only to do; but never the right over the results thereof...”

 – Bhagavad Gita-Chapter II-verse 47

67

Both the purification of the mind and thereby its ability to discriminate rightly grow simultaneously in the aspirant. 

Therefore, as his mind becomes purer and purer it gets the high clarity through which his power of understanding becomes sharper and sharper. 

Now only, with this, he is able to understand the necessity of rightly knowing the Self, and how the appearance of the world and God is connected with Self knowledge and also,

 how purification of the mind is the sole aim of Karma Yoga, as it has been explained so far in this chapter.

 Indeed, what greater benefit than this clarity of mind is worthy to be attained through Karma Yoga?

 For, the aspirant is now really qualified for the science of Self by which the Supreme Truth will dawn in him! 

It is this process that is pointed out in the verse 3 of ‘Upadesha Undiyar’ by Sri Bhagavan referred to previously.

If we know what is the impurity in the mind, the way in which it is removed by the practice of Karma Yoga will also be clearly understood; ‘I’ and ‘mine’ are the impurities in the mind or ‘Chittam’. If these impurities which form the ‘tam’ in ‘Chittam’ are removed,‘Chittam’ will remain as ‘Chit’ (Pure Consciousness) which it really ever IS.

“Just like a colourless prism appears to be red when near a red flower, Chit (Consciousness) appears to be chittam – the mind, when the impurities ‘I’ and ‘mine’ are superimposed on It. When these, which are caused by Maya, are removed it shines as ever as Chit”. 

- Guru Vachaka Kovai - Verse No. 244

..

waves inseparable from ocean.

all existence rooted in being.

.........

‘I’ and ‘mine’ are the root-impurities of all other innumerable impurities such as lust, anger and the like. Even out of these two, the possessive form ‘mine’ can have an existence only because of ‘I’. Where there is no ‘I’, there will be no ‘mine’. 

Though in its pure nature ‘I’ is the Self, it is taken to be impure because of its attributes which are alien to it and experienced as ‘I’ am-this, I am-this body, ‘I am-a man or I am-so and so’. 

Hence, the attributes appended to ‘I AM’ alone, are the ‘root-impurity’.

 Till this impurities are removed, Self, Existence-Consciousness (Sat-Chit) is called ego. 

The true purpose of Yoga is only to remove this root-impurity. 

The methods of removing the impurities vary according to the maturity of the aspirants.

 Consequently different Yogas had to be framed.

 To the aspirants who are very intent on removing their impurities, the impurity in the form of ‘mine’ being gross rather than the impurity in the form of ‘I’ which is subtle, come first within the range of their perception.

 Then, one with sincere yearning, at once starts rejecting every thing saying, “Let it not be for me”. This leads to renunciation.

 Another type of aspirant kindles within himself the feeling of sacrifice saying, “Let all these (of mine) be for others and not for me”*. 

Karma Yoga is framed having the principle of the second type of aspirant as its base!

Thus out of the two impurities ‘I’ and ‘mine’, as ‘mine’ is easily noticeable, it is no wonder that all good people with noble aspiration generally first try to tackle only the ‘mine-ness’. For, such a mind which is thus purified through the renunciation of ‘mine-ness’ another truth also will dawn :- “This ‘mine’ is just like the leaves and branches of a tree. No matter with what effort and how many times they are cut, the leaves and branches -‘mine-ness’ – will, under favourable conditions, keep on sprouting again and again in some form or other in their own time. Therefore, the root ‘I’ should be traced out and annihilated”

Even for this truth to dawn, is it not necessary that the restless intensity of ‘mine-ness’ should be lessened to a very great extent? Until this understanding comes to an earnest seeker through the proper discrimination of the purified mind that ‘I’ is the right root-impurity and that it has to be rooted out, service to humanity, sacrifice for others and similar unselfish activities in the line of Karma Yoga will be going on in his life making up the major part of his endeavour. Then, according to his previous tendencies and tastes he steps into either the path of devotion (Bhakti Yoga) or the path of knowledge (Jnana Yoga) which alone are directly concerned with the annihilation of the ego, the root-impurity. He who was all this time being carried along by the current of the tributary Jamuna, has now been handed over to the Ganges, the mother river. Here the Jamuna symbolizes the path of Karma (Karma Yoga) while the Ganges symbolizes both the path of Love (Bhakti Yoga) and the path of Knowledge (Jnana Yoga). These two are, like the Ganges, ever flowing into the ocean of Brahman unfailingly taking along the aspirant who falls into their current.

To attain Existence–Consciousness–Bliss (Sat-Chit-Ananda), the Self or Brahman, Consciousness (Chit) and Bliss (Ananda) themselves act as the two Paths i.e., to reach Existence, the Supreme (Sat), Consciousness (Chit) and Bliss (Ananda or Priya) are the only Paths. The Path of Consciousness (Chit) is the Path of Knowledge (Jnana Marga) and the Path of Bliss (Ananda) is the Path of Love (Bhakti Marga). To say the truth, Brahman, the Sat itself stretches its two arms – Consciousness (Chit) and Bliss (Ananda) – to draw us to itself or in other words lays Itself down under our feet as the Path of Knowledge and the Path of Love for us to tread upon. Thus, the holy words, “I am the Path and I am the Goal” are proved. The Path is to attend to ‘I am’ and the Goal is to remain as ‘I am’!

Bhakti

78

So also, Love or Bhakti has different degrees of superiority or inferiority according to the different degrees of the purity of the mind of jeevas. 

In this manner, the love or Bhakti present in different jeevas can be classified into five classes. The fully purified love will shine as Shiva!

1st std vishaya bhakti

2nd std vishaya bhakti alone, but names and forms of god means to fulfill them

3rd std worshipping only 1 god

3A- love for objects not for god

3b love for god

4 - ripened love for guru. complete dispassion for worldly objects

5 love for guru replaced by Love for Self  (pg 151 end )


95

The main point of Yoga is to collect the scattered thoughts into one and fix the mind on that one thought only. 

The worship of God is a means to focus the mind on one point, setting aside the other innumerable thoughts concerning one’s daily activities rising (in one) during the waking state. 

In the Path of Love (Bhakti Marga) when such confidence in God: 

“God will look after everything in my life; why should I think and worry about it” 

increases,

then  thousands of unnecessary thoughts will depart.

 But this alone is not sufficient. 

The important point in Bhakti Yoga is to fix the mind on one name and form of God, and not change the worship from one name and form of God to another and thereby allowing the mind to branch out into so many thoughts and waver.

“By association with Sat – the Truth, the attachment (towards worldly objects) goes away...”

 – ‘Ulladu Narpadu – Supplement’ - verse 1.

“My child, what are you lacking? Why do you call me so anxiously? What happened to you?”

 The Man answers:- “O Lord, forgive me for my mistake of loving the objects of the world instead of loving You, the perfect Love Itself.” 


“O Annamalai, Form of Love itself! Thou hast claimed me who have no such love to make me think of Thee and pine for Thee and melt me like fire melts wax. 

Does it befit Thee now to let me waste away by failing to bestow upon me the love for Thee? 

O Bliss born out of Love!

 O Nectar springing up in the heart of Thy devotees! 

What can I say to Thee! 

Thy will is my will and that itself is my happiness, O Lord of my life! 


–‘Sri Arunachala Pathikam’ - verse 2  


“O Supreme! I am the foremost of those who do not have such excellent discrimination as to give up all worldly attachments and cling only to Thy Feet. 

Taking all my burden as yours, ordain the ‘mine’ in all actions to cease. 

What indeed can be a burden to Thee that sustaineth the whole universe? O Lord, enough of the trouble I have had by leaving Thee and by bearing the burden of this world on my head. O Arunachala, who art the Lord! Think no more of keeping me away from Thy Feet.” 

– ‘Sri Arunachala Pathikam’- verse 9 

“O Arunachala, like a magnet attracts iron and cannot release it, attract me and without leaving me, be ever in union with me.” 

–‘Arunachala Aksharamanamalai’ - verse 16.

 “O Arunachala, as ice dissolves in water (and becomes water), dissolve me in Love, in Thee, the form of Love.” –‘Arunachala Aksharamanamalai’ - verse 101.

“From now onwards there is no such thing for me as a need in my life. Let anything take place in my life as you will ” “… all such sorts of ups and downs, happiness or misery, prosperity or poverty, honour or dishonour, fame or ill-fame…” The only need is You alone; fulfill that one need of mine, my Lord! – Sri Ramalinga Swamy

111

preme. “For Thee I am longing, but without the true knowledge, and I am weary! Do Thou grant me the Supreme Knowledge of Thee, so That my weariness may go, O Arunachala.” – ‘Arunachala Aksharamanamalai’ – Verse 40


...imp......


Knowing that the present pangs of separation of our Man are due to his love for Him (God) 

and this in turn is due to not having the right knowledge of His reality, 

(Real Nature) 

and that the only remedy for this is to bestow upon him the Supreme Knowledge; 

God withdraws from the sight of the Man His unreal aspects, the name and form.


 The Man now wonders aimlessly like an insane; sometimes walking, sometimes stopping, endlessly and untiringly cries out in agony and calls “Krishna, O Krishna” in low or high pitch. 

He has become God mad, having no thoughts for wife, children, house or work. 

But he remains drowned in the meditation on his Beloved Krishna 

Who has overwhelmed him even without his effort! 

This Man who is now suffering from the pangs of separation, is just in the same state of mind as Saint Appar on his way to see Lord Shiva in Kailas;

 Sri Ramakrishna who even tried to kill himself weeping for his Divine Mother Kali; Sri Chaitanya who became mad for Sri Krishna; Sita who when imprisoned in Lanka (Ceylon) was longing for Sri Rama and Bharata who searched for Sri Rama in the forest. 

Sometimes even some more lives (Janmas) may pass in this state of pangs of separation!

no matter how much, one is able to get the company of one of the names and forms of God, that cannot be the state of permanent attainment of God; soon or later that name and form will have to vanish.

 “… realizing one’s own truth in the truth of that True Thing (the Supreme) and being one with It, having been resolved into It, is the true Seeing (realization). Thus should you know”. 

– ‘Ulladu Narpadu’ – Verse 8.

Realising the oneness of one’s own Self as the true nature of God and to merge into It without any residue of individuality, alone is the true seeing and the true attainment of God. 

Is it not?

117

It is to be noted here that, though Namdev recognised that every space (for second and third persons) are a place for the Shivalingam; the True Knowledge did not blossom in him, until his attention was drawn to his own SELF, the first person, by the action of placing the Feet on his own head. Only then the Truth was realised. 

This clearly proves the ‘teaching of Sri Bhagavan Ramana that, unless one experiences one’s Self, the knowledge that everything is Brahman cannot be perfect and true; 

although one accepts that everything is Brahman and tries to see the world as such; it will be only an imagination.


“...when the first person (ego) ceases to be, through enquiry into the truth of the first person, the second and third persons come to an end. That state of Being in which all (I, II and III persons) shine as one, is the true nature of the Self” –Ulladu Narpadu, - Verse 14.


The knowing of your Self (Sat) is spontaneously ever present, because you are Knowledge itself. 

So also, even any feeling of love in you cannot be but you, because you are Love itself.


“Even though one may worship the Supreme in whatever form, giving (Him) whatever name, and even though it is the way to see the Supreme in that name and form, realising one’s own Truth in the truth of that True Thing (the Supreme), and being one with It having been resolved into It, is the only true seeing. Thus should you know.” 

-‘Ulladu Narpadu’ - Verse 8*


 134

Where is the time for him, in the flood of his intense yearning for the Supreme Truth, to repent over the days wasted with those gurus or to feel hate or disregard towards them? He goes ahead forgetting them!

144

 Guru is the Self. 

Attaining the Self alone is to attain God or Guru. 

On the other hand, so long as you see your God or Guru as different from your Self, you cannot know the Self which is the state of Perfect Freedom. 


So long as there is the feeling of separateness, fear is bound to be there. If you want to be free from fear (the state of fearlessness) be in the state of otherlesness, Self.

Your Love of the Self (Swatma Bhakti) i.e., your (ego’s) merging into the Self, is verily your true Love of the Guru (Guru-Bhakti).

The love that springs upon other things can never be the full one (poorna). 

When love is full (poorna), the defect in the form of the movement of springing upon other things will not be there. 

The fullness of love unbroken and all-pervading is ‘Not with an other (Non-dual)’. 

He alone who has love, but ‘Not for an other’ (Ananya Bhakti) is one who has the Full Love (Sampoorna Bhakti).


147

When love abides as itself, it is the full and perfect Love. When the Love takes the form of movement, it is fragmented and becomes desire which springs upon other objects. It is Love when it is in the form of unbroken Existence; it is desire when it is in the form of movement or fragmentation.

“...Remaining in one’s own real Beingness is the very truth of Supreme Love” –‘Upadesha Undiyar’ - Verse 9

So long as you think that your Guru’s Divine Love towards you is a love that springs from one entity to an other, certainly this love (your Guru’s love towards you) is to be taken as a divided love. Therefore, it is a lesser one than your love towards Self. “…

One who has such ‘Love for not an other’ drowns in Thee, the Self the form of Bliss.” –‘Sri Arunachala Pancharatnam’ Verse 5

Though one’s love for oneself is the greatest of all love towards any other objects in the world, when the true Love for the Guru (true Guru Bhakti) dawns,

the love felt by the disciple towards the Guru is greater than even the love towards oneself, the ego. But while experiencing the truth of the Self, the love towards the real Self is found to be greater than one’s love even towards one’s Guru. All this time it has been said that one loves oneself more than anything else because of the love towards the Self. But, as everyone is under the wrong idea that the ego is one’s Self (because ego is a false entity; a reflection of the Self) one does not experience the love towards the real Self. 

When the Guru who is verily his Self, comes in front of the disciple who is fully matured as to be able to have real Love for Guru (Guru Bhakti), 

he, the disciple is able to feel his love towards the Self 

- but only in the human form in front of him. 

Hence it has been pointed out above that the love felt towards the Guru is even greater than the love felt towards oneself, the ego. 

Though his Guru is his Self and although his love towards his Guru is indirectly Self-love, so long as he sees his Guru – his Self – as a second person, his love towards his Guru is not fully refined into the Self Love, until he experiences his Guru within as his Self. 

That is why the Guru now proves and convinces our Man that his Love for the Guru (Guru Bhakti) is less than his love for the Self (Swatma Bhakti). 

Yes, but, why has it been said that even the Guru’s love towards the disciple is less than one’s Love towards the Self? 

In the view of the Guru, there is no one other than the Self. 

Therefore, His love is truly not a love towards a second entity as disciple. The Guru never views anyone as a disciple – an other than Himself.

But, as the Guru pointed out to the disciple that, so long as the disciple thinks that the Guru is a separate entity, he (the disciple) has to consider the Guru’s love to be a love from one entity to another. 

Truly it is not so; because the Guru never sees him as a second. 

That is why, even the Guru’s love towards the disciple (which is only in the disciple’s view) is explained as being inferior. 

If we, with this in mind, listen to the following words of Sri Ramana, “I have neither Guru nor disciple”, we shall be able to understand what He really meant. One who is truly the Guru cannot see anyone as disciple. A Guru is a Guru only in the view of the disciple.

Thus, when the rain water – the Man, is fully absorbed in the vast lake of his Love for his Guru (Guru Bhakti), the Guru stirs him to break away the bank of the lake i.e., the limitation of his Love for the Guru and makes the rain water – the Man, flow into the ocean of Bliss, the Self. 

Because of his excellent fitness the Man, who was listening to the words of his Guru with rapt attention, was able, at the very time of hearing about the Truth (shravana) to complete his reflections (manana) and practices (nidhidhyasana) simultaneously. 

He becomes speechless, thoughtless and motionless. 

He remains drowned in the ocean of Supreme Silence

As the river – the Man reaches its source, the ocean – the Self, the motion of running – the action – effort ceases completely. When the feeling of love has thus been refined to perfection through the aforesaid course,

 the Man is promoted from the Love for the Guru (Guru Bhakti) to the Love for the Self (Swatma Bhakti) i.e., from IVth to Vth standard of our School. 

The Man, being now freed from the confusion in the form of desire, fear and delusion which he had on account of the wrong outlook of seeing his own Self as multiplicity is well established in the Self through Self-attention. 

This Self-abidance indeed is the acme of LOVE.

 Hence forth, according to the criteria given in the work, everyone of us should examine oneself and find out into which standard one fits and try to qualify for the next. 

This examination of ourselves as to whether our love is a love for objects (vishaya bhakti) or a truly interested Love for God (Daiva Bhakti), should be very sincere, lest we deceive ourselves by overestimating our qualification and be temporarily contented.

152

But, if after attending the School in any of the Ist, IInd and IIIrd (a) standard, one feels that it is better to revert to the aforesaid worldly life, one becomes a Yoga Bhrashta (one fallen from Yoga). 

Such a thing has no chance to happen for those who have reached the IIIrd(b) standard. 

There may be some aspirants who believing that they are in IIIrd (a) standard become dispirited as they do not obtain the fulfilment of all their desires and decide to read again the Ist or IInd standard text books, which means that they are fit only for those lower standards. 

Some among us, are in the habit of going to many gurus and showing their love to them saying : 

“My aim is Liberation only, and not any of the pleasures of this world and of the next. Therefore mine is the Love for the Guru (Guru Bhakti), and I have the right qualification for my being in the IVth standard of the School”. 

Some others having the same thought, are in the habit of visiting so many temples of different names and forms of God saying also that their aim is Liberation only. Because they state that, they do not want any of the pleasures of the world and, that they desire Liberation only, they have to be considered as belonging to IIIrd ( b) standard; 

or because they visit many gurus, it seems that they may have Guru Bhakti, the qualification for the IVth standard. 

It is not so, since their going to different gurus is nothing but going to different names and forms, their love, not being focussed on one point only, is weakened by being scattered towards so many different directions and becomes inefficient to go deep into the instructions of any of the gurus and follow them. They get no real benefit from the teachings of those gurus. Suppose we see one of our friends coming out of a restaurant and entering another one – what does it mean? Does this not show that he has taken nothing to satisfy his hunger from that restaurant? If again we see him coming out of even that restaurant and going to another one, it means that he is still starving! Should he had eaten anything in anyone of the restaurants, would he not return directly to his lodging? Some explain away their actions with such lame excuses: “In that restaurant the rice is well cooked; so I take it from there. In this other one sambar* is excellent; the vegetables are tasty in the third one; there is a fresh supply of vadai* and appalam* daily in the fourth one; so I go there!” This is exactly like one saying, “I learn Hathayoga and Pranayama from that guru; I take initiations of Mantras from another. When I go to that guru I practise Karma-Yoga. I am taught Bhakti Yoga by still another one. I practise Vasi-Yoga (a form of Pranayama) with this guru and I am explained Advaita by that one......... Therefore, I go to all these great ones!” What does this really mean? Not even one of these gurus is understood rightly!

“When the mind remains permanently absorbed in its source whence it had its rising – it is Karma, Bhakti; it is Yoga and Jnana also.” – ‘Upadesha Undiyar’ - Verse 10

The Guru Bhakti in the IVth standard is like the chastity of the wife towards her husband. This is why we call the Guru as ‘Guru-Natha’ or ‘Divine Husband’

“To say the truth, he who knows the Truth (MeiJnani) is different from he who knows of the Truth in the scriptures (Vijnani). The only essential thing to do for those who want to cut the knot of the bondage of ignorance, is to quit those who know the scriptures and to join those who abide in the Self, the Knowers of Truth.” –‘Guruvachaka Kovai’ - Verse 1158

“He who orders” ‘do’s and ‘don’ts” to those who come to him is both Death (Yama) and the Creator (Brahma) to them. But the truly Divine Guru is one who proves them that nothing is to be accomplished newly by them.” – Guruvachaka Kovai’ - Verse 271*

157

“My Guru is a Jnani. He totally condemns occult powers (Siddhis). But I would like to acquire them. My mind cannot be at rest until I get Siddhis. I don’t worry about taking many more births; but I want Siddhis along with Jnana and not Jnana only…..” “My Guru often advises us to merge within unmindful of the world; but I prefer doing unselfish service (Karma Yoga) for my country and for the whole world. I feel that a life of service to humanity is better than the life of one who remains quietly in a remote cave.”... “My Guru teaches the Path of Love; but my mind is inclined towards Raja-Yoga” “The aim of my Guru is this (pointing out the heart), but mine is that (pointing out to the top of the head)”. The so-called disciples who are making such controversial statements about the teachings of the Gurus, are not the fit disciples to those Gurus and it is not for such people that those Gurus have come. We have to know that to adhere entirely to the teachings of one’s Guru, without any reservation such as one’s own inclination, principle, aim, wishes etc.. is to have Sad-Guru Bhakti as Sri Bhagavan Ramana declares in verse two of Arunachala Patikam, “... 

What have I to say? Thy will is my will and that Itself is my happiness, O Lord of my life, Arunachala !”

From what we have seen above we come to understand that Jnana and Bhakti – Consciousness (Chit) and Bliss (Ananda) are the real aspects of Brahman. As Brahman is Existence (Sat) and Sat is the Reality, Bhakti and Jnana – the real aspects of Brahman – are nothing but Sat, the Reality, i.e., the real Bhakti or the real Jnana are nothing but Brahman Itself. According to the Supreme Teaching:

 “ Brahman alone shines directly as ‘I-I’, - the Atman” –Ulladu Narpadu, Supp. - Verse 8 

Bhakti and Jnana pave the way to the Self. To be as the Self is Jnana; and without loving the Self how to be It? So, if one is as Self, it is the state of fullness of Love. If one has ‘Bhakti one cannot but be as the Self. So Bhakti and Jnana are not two but the Self, like the two faces of the same coin. 

“Without the power of gravitation, can anything remain stable on earth? So also, the pull of gravitation is Bhakti; the remaining stable is Jnana. Therefore, neither of them can remain without the other.” – ‘Sadanai Saram’

The attainment of the Self is the highest aim of the Vedas; and that alone is the real teaching of Bhagavan Ramana. That Path of Knowledge, i.e., the enquiry ‘Who am I?’ which results in the dawning of Self-Knowledge is explained as ‘The Path of Sri Ramana’ (Part One).

 Now, as the love in its perfectly refined state shines as Self alone, the method of purifying the love up to Self-Love (Swatma Bhakti) is explained as ‘The Path of Sri Ramana’ (Part Two).

As the nature of the love in the human being varies from the primitive man, to the man who abides in the Self, different grades of instructions are taught by the scriptures to uplift the people step by step. This explains why, different types of teachers are necessary to teach the different grades. Scholars in scriptures, instructors on Mantras, Yantras, Tantras etc., expounders (Pravachanakarthas) of holy texts (Puranas and Ithihasas) – though not knowers of the Self, but only students up to the IIIrd standard of our School – are necessary throughout the world throughout ages. To help these students – teachers are necessary for the aspirants who are in a lower standard, until those aspirants are promoted to the next standard. Their preaching of the principles of ethics, devotion to God,

importance of Karmas, dispassion towards worldly enjoyments – let us not care whether they follow and acquire knowledge and experience of their own teachings – is always needed for the progress of humanity. But, as it is always seen that they compel their followers to believe that whatever they preach alone is final, and to become fanatics to such an extent of hating all other instructions for further progress when presented to them; we should be careful to see that our own understanding does not get confused by them. We should ourselves, try to find out the standard to which we belong in the School of purification of love with the help of clarifications given above; but, at the same time we should not have any kind of abhorrence towards those teachers, teachings and thoughts with their various peculiar ideas about God, goal, service etc. We should have love and tolerance towards them rather than objecting to their clinging to Karmas etc. Unless they come to us completely disgusted with their practices and ask for a better truth, we should not interfere and disturb the course of others. Let us encourage every one of them in their own way

162 ...bhakti ends..


............Karma .......................162


But, as the Power of Willing (Ichcha Shakti) is extroverted through the mind, senses and body, the result is that the individual separates himself more and more away from Happiness, the Source.

172

But, as the Power of Willing (Ichcha Shakti) is extroverted through the mind, senses and body, the result is that the individual separates himself more and more away from Happiness, the Source.

lose his balance of mind and therefore he is able to endure the Prarabdha cheerfully. In this case the fruit of the experiencing of the Prarabdha will be according to God’s expectation, i.e., to mature one’s mind for a speedy attainment of the Goal. Thus we may conclude 

(a): we have the original freedom to yield or not to yield to the Will of God; 

(b) by yielding to His Will our progress is improved and accelerated; 

(c) by not yielding to His Will, our progress is minimised and retarded and we will have to undergo a similar experience of Prarabdha in future births so that we may progress, as we could have done in this birth itself, had we yielded to the Will of God.

173

Some may ask whether even God cannot change or arrest the Prarabdha. As God is the Ordainer of Prarabdha He has the Perfect Freedom either to change or arrest the experiencing of Prarabdha, if one completely surrenders to Him, praying to him, “O my Lord, You know my inability to endure the sufferings; protect me by bestowing the strength of endurance”, then only, as our original freedom is not used in the way of preventing Him, He can do anything as He wishes; i.e., either to allow the Prarabdha, change it or stop it.

 This is exactly what is proclaimed by Sage Auvaiyar when she said, 

“For those who surrender in Shiva (Shivaya nama) there is no possibility of danger befalling them. This alone is Free Will. If not surrendered, every thing will become Fate.” 

Not only can He change or arrest the Prarabdba, but He can also order the Agamya to give fruit immediately by including it in the Prarabdha. 

The story of Markandeya is an illustration for the former and the story of Adi Shankara and the poor woman for the latter.

 A brief sketch of each story is given below:- 

1. Though according to Prarabdha the lifespan of Markandeya was only sixteen years, he obtained the preservation of his life by surrendering to Lord Shiva. 

2. While Adi Shankara was begging for His food, a poor lady gave Him a small fruit, but through the window of her hut! It then became known to Adi Shankara that she was so poor as not to be able to open the door for the lack of clothing (on her body) to give Him the fruit through the door. A great compassion rose in His heart. He composed verses in praise of Goddess Lakshmi* (Kanakadhara Stotram). When the Goddess appeared to Him, Adi Shankara asked Her to grant wealth to that poor lady. Goddess Lakshmi pointed out that there was no provision in her Prarabdha which He Himself, Lord Shankara, had ordained. Adi Shankara recommended that the present charitable act of that poor woman in giving the small fruit to Him, should be included in her Prarabdha and wealth granted to her, then and there. At once there was a shower of gold fruits for her in answer to the recommendation of Adi Shankara. Here it is shown that the fruit of Agamya can be included into the Prarabdha by the Ordainer. The second mistake one commits through the ‘original freedom to will and act’ is, beginning to do Agamyas while at the same time allowing the Prarabdha to take its course; i.e., the individual, being compelled by his likes and dislikes to increase the happiness and to remove the miseries in future births, begins to do Agamya. Because he does not know that happiness is his own nature, he engages himself in so many different karmas, wishfully thinking that he can obtain happiness with the help of his mind, senses, body and objects of the world. In this manner, at the time of the death of the body, innumerable Agamyas are added to the already piled up Himalayas of his Sanchita making it grow higher and higher.

“The results of actions having passed away after being experienced, leaving seeds (vasanas – tendencies), cast the agent into an ocean of action. Therefore, the results of actions yield not Liberation.” – ‘Upadesha Undiyar’ - Verse 2

Thus with his ‘original freedom to will and act’ man commits two kinds of mistakes. How to rectify these two mistakes? At this stage the God who, according to the conception of the man, is other than himself and All-knowing, All-powerful and All-merciful, shows compassion towards him and when the man who has been suffering throughout so many births in the past, prays to Him that it is His duty to give him the Right-Knowledge, comes to his help. Is it not He who, as we have already said in the previous chapter ‘Bhakti’, when prayed to by the Man for the attainment of worldly objects, gave him the portion of ‘Karma Kandas’ of the Vedas as a Teacher

 for the 1st and IInd standards of our School, as well as the fruits of his karmas? He now answering his prayers, comes to him in the form of a Guru to help him to find out how he has committed the above two mistakes through his ‘original freedom to will and act’ and to teach him how to use correctly that freedom. To this individual who, having forgotten his Real State of Bliss through his own ‘freedom to will and act’, is now suffocating for happiness, making efforts in the form of karmas with his limited power and knowledge; who else can be a real helper except his loving God? For, He knows that to completely fulfil his desire for happiness is nothing else but, to remove his state of forgetfulness of Self, making him thus become aware of his Original State.

Now, God makes use of the Sanchita of the individual in such a way that will help him to get True Knowledge. Is not a portion of the Sanchita of the individual selected and allotted as Prarabdha whenever he takes a birth? The karmas will be selected by God as Prarabdha in such a way, i.e., what kind of karmas (good or bad), at what time (in which circumstances of which birth) and in which way (the order of priority to, experience pain or pleasure) that while experiencing the results of those karmas the individual will grow more and more disgusted and, will be drawn to the conclusion that performing karmas is useless. This is His boundless Grace! Is it not?

Not knowing this, but yet believing that God is All-powerful, All-knowing and All-merciful, if the man compellingly prays to Him: “Change my destiny (Prarabdha), add more to my happiness and lessen the

miseries in my destiny”; instead of completely surrendering himself to Him, that is only ignorance; it is only finding fault, on account of his little intellect, with God’s plan. What does his prayer show? It shows only that he accuses God, whom he praised to be All knowing, not to be wise enough to determine his Prarabdha properly! i.e., he makes the ‘All-knowing’ – ‘not knowing’! 

In the same manner, when the miseries in his Prarabdha are not removed by his prayers, he is dejected. What does this dejection show? It shows that he feels God, whom he praised to be All-powerful is not that powerful enough, to stop his miseries, i.e., through his dejection he makes the ‘All-powerful’ – ‘not powerful’!! Not only this; when he tries to find a reason why God does not stop his miseries, he concludes that He is not willing to do so; what does this conclusion show? It shows that he declares God, whom he praised to be All-merciful, not to be kind in helping him, i.e., through his conclusion he makes the ‘All-merciful’ – ‘merciless’!!! Does it not?

What makes him do so? Is it not his desire for the cessation of miseries and the attainment of happiness? Even a person who is now enjoying a happy life, fears some future unexpected miseries and he worries; or he may be longing for an even happier life in future. 

Another man who is now suffering, is wistfully longing for the day when the miseries will come to an end and, be replaced by happiness. For these reasons we like to know the future course of our life; but, this is an unnecessary mental activity. Someone asked Sri Bhagavan Ramana: “Can we know about our past lives and about the future of our present life and about our future births?”

 Sri Bhagavan answered:- “If the man, who is confused and much worried with the thoughts about his present activities, is given to understand the past and future, will he not be even more confused and miserable? Will his life then not become a hell! It is only ignorance to search for the knowledge of the past and future, while ignoring to know the truth of his present as ‘Who am I?”.

“...Without knowing the truth of the present, seeking to know the past and future, is like trying to count without knowing the nature of ‘one’, the unit.” – ‘Ulladu Narpadu’ - Verse 15

If an aspirant says that he is longing for Liberation, but at the same time shows a great deal of interest in those arts and crafts, he cannot be a real devotee or a real enquirer. For, a real devotee will never ask God to alter his Prarabdha because he has surrendered his ‘original freedom to will and act’ to Him; no more a real enquirer will make an effort towards any other thing except to attend to the Self, because he knows the right use of his ‘original freedom to will and act’.

 If he is really a devotee or an enquirer (i.e., a student in the IIIrd (b) or IVth standard of our School) will he have a taste or even the slightest inclination towards these arts and crafts? He will certainly not; for hecannot! 

Should he do so, it only betrays, in the three ways his lack of love and faith in God. The necessity of these arts and crafts has to vanish in the state of complete surrender. Thus sings Manickavachakar:--

“The very moment You took me as Your own, I lost my individuality! You may do good or wrong to me! Who am I to interfere, O my Lord!”

From what has been said above it would be wrong if any reader comes to the conclusion that we are declaring that those arts and crafts are bogus or that we hate them. But, let the reader know that we merely conclude that they are good only for the students in Ist, IInd and IIIrd (a) standards of our School, but not at all necessary to an aspirant aiming for the Truth only.

If we really have love and faith in God, we should unconditionally surrender ourselves to Him as it is said by Sri Bhagavan Ramana:

 “O Annamalai... Can I have then any grievance? O my (real) Soul, do whatever Thou wilt; but grant me, O Beloved, only ever increasing love for Thy Feet.” 

-‘Sri Arunachala Navamani Malai’ - Verse 7


“O Arunachala….O Bliss born out of Love! What is there for me to say? Thy Will is my will and Thy Will is Itself my happiness.” 

-‘Sri Arunachala Pathikam’ - Verse 2


It is such devotee alone who, knowing this well and accepting it, was mentioned in the previous

chapter as a qualified student in the IVth standard of our School. 

And it is only to such student that the method of rectifying the two mistakes in using the ‘freedom to will and act’, mentioned above, can be explained. Verily, only for the sake of such few devotees, who by experiencing the results of karmas through so many births have been maturing through dispassion towards karmas, 

God comes in the form of a Guru! 

At first the individual thinks that the Guru in front of him is a man Iike himself. 

But, as the Guru is really none other but his very Self - which is Love, it is no wonder that he feels such a natural, boundless. 

irresistable flow of love springing forth towards his Guru

The Guru now instructs him how to handle his ‘original freedom to will and act’:- “Using your freedom to know the Reality, your Self, is the only right use. If you do not know or cannot do that, handover or surrender completely that freedom to God; so that He may use it on your behalf in any way He likes. That means, either know the right way of using it, or restore it to the hands of God, who knows how to use it”. Thus the Guru places in front of the disciple the path of Self-enquiry and the path of Self-surrender – the path of Knowledge and the path of Love (Jnana Marga and Bhakti Marga).

From that time onwards the devotee, who takes to either Self-enquiry or Self-surrender, is able to understand that whatever happens in his life is only favourable to lessen the activities of his mind and make him turn Self-ward. 

Not only that, he is also able to understand that whatever has happened to him in the past through his Prarabdha as ordained by God,

 before he took to his present spiritual path, were also incidents favourable to lessen the activities of his mind and make him turn Self-ward. To the disciple who is now wondering about his new outlook on life, these loving words of Sri Ramana flash through his mind:- “Know this to be by the Grace of your Guru who is acting from outside to push you within.”

183 imp

As soon as he gets this new outlook on life, he feels ashamed to pray any longer to his God or Guru to alter his destiny (Prarabdha); because, he now finds that all the activities going on in his life are only to make him turn Self-ward. 

In short, in the eyes of such a matured disciple, the Prarabdha becomes completely non-existent. 

He does not use the word ‘Prarabdha’, 

but points out to it as ‘The loving Will of my Lord; 

His Will is my pleasure!’. 

Now the surrender completes itself 

– the life has been changed into one immense Bliss, 

even the greatest tortures now appear to him, 

[as sings Saint Appar:

* “(Where I was placed) under the shade of the Feet of my Lord, I felt as if on the cool bank of a pond in the spring full moon, under the pleasant touch of the southern breeze while the Veena is playing sweet melody”.

His mind so transformed is no longer a ‘mind’, It is Self – his very nature.

We can say that, what was previously called ‘mind’ is now destroyed. Thus we are able to understand that the experiencership 

(Bhoktrutva) is destroyed along with the doership (Kartrutva). 

Having his two aspects thus destroyed, the jeeva’s keeping quite is the ‘BE STILL’ (Summa Iru). 

And THIS is the real teaching (Upadesha) of the Guru. 

To BE so STILL is the real service to God and to the Guru. 

And to BE so STILL is really to live in the Divine. 

And THIS is the original Natural State.


To will to be so still, i.e., to like to be so still, or to will not to be so still, i.e., to do, is under one’s will. For, the ‘Perfect Freedom to will and act’ is one’s very nature – Brahman, the Self.

It is said above that the destruction of the doership is itself the destruction of the experiencership also. 

The same power – our Perfect Freedom, which imagined a separate entity as a doer, when now, on the contrary, acts in the form of an intense Power to Will (Ichcha Shakti) and an intense Power to Act (Kriya Shakti) to BE STILL,

 this un-equalled Power - the DYNAMIC STILLNESS destroys the insignificant, false and imaginary ‘ichcha and kriya shakti’ used for the creation, sustenance and destruction of the universe.


At this stage, the unnatural superimposition made by the aforesaid power of imagination to see the Self, by the Self, in the Self - as many, ceases! 

Now, as the aspirant experiences the real Awakening into his True Nature which ever shines as ONE with no otherness – the Perfect SELF alone, the sleep of ignorance in which the dream of birth and death of the individual (the doer) appeared, disappears!! When the doership is thus destroyed, who stands there for experiencership? 

Hence, the heap or Sanchita, with its good and bad results of the karmas performed, disappears like a dream, just as both debts and gains in a dream disappear on waking-up. 

It is what is mentioned in ‘Kaivalyam’.

“Just as a bundle of cotton is burnt to ashes, during the Great Fire of Dissolution, Sanchita, the wonderful seed of diversified fruits – innumerable births - is utterly burnt to ashes by the Fire of Knowledge.” – ‘Kaivalyam’ - Chapter I -Verse 96. 

and in Bhagavad Gita:--

 “ ... The Fire of Knowledge burns ALL karmas to ashes.” –‘Bhagavad Gita’ - Chapter IV - Verse 37. 

It has already been said that there will be no more Agamya after the doership has been destroyed. Up till now it has been said in scriptures, to pacify the questioners, that the Prarabdha which remains after Sanchita and Agamya have been destroyed is to be experienced, and that it will end only with the death of the body. But, it is to be understood that this is not said for those fully mature aspirants who have a keen discrimination. For, they are expected to apply here a little reflection, i.e., since the doership and the experiencership are the two faces of the jeeva, the individual (like the two faces of a coin), how can the experiencership still live after the doership has been destroyed by the dawn of Self-Knowledge? It cannot!

 When the experiencership is thus lost, who is there to experience the Prarabdha and how? No one! Will not the Prarabdha be nullified since there is no experiencer? Therefore, for the Jnani there is truly none of the three Karmas; but, as an ignorant and immature aspirant takes the Jnani to be a body – he cannot do otherwise - the scriptures have to tell him that the Jnani has Prarabdha alone. That is why the Supreme, who takes the form of different Gurus at different times to frame rules – the different scriptures – now appearing in the form of Sri Ramana, gives for the benefit of the highly mature souls, the following amendment to the scriptures, which He had Himself framed at different times:-

“To say that Sanchita and Agamya will not adhere to a Jnani, but Prarabdha does remain (to be experienced by Him) is only a superficial reply to the question put by others. Just as none of the wives will remain unwidowed when the husband dies, so also, all the three Karmas will cease to exist when the doer (ego) dies. Thus should you know” - ‘Ulladu Narpadu – Supplement’ - Verse 33

The aspirant who is on the path of Love (Bhakti) believes that there is a God or Guru and that He protects him, with the hope that He will do for him whatever is good. Such an aspirant, while using his ‘original freedom to will and act’, surrenders his doership to Him; therefore he, no longer has to make efforts (Agamyas), and thus BEcomes STILL.

There is another kind of aspirants who, not believing in God or Guru, deeply scrutinize the nature

of their efforts and activities while experiencing the different joys and trials of life and who finally come to understand the right use of their ‘original freedom to will and act’. Through their ‘original freedom to will and act’ they withdraw their attention from second and third person objects and by attending to the Self, giving no room for (imaginary) inattention in their quest, they try to regain the Truth of the Self – the state of actionless-ness. Thus they BEcome STILL.

The freedom to like either; to make a complete surrender to God or to dispel the ignorance – in the form of an imaginary inattention, through Self-enquiry, and the freedom to act accordingly is in the individual; never it is obstructed; for, it is the very nature of Brahman. But for this freedom alone, Moksha or Liberation or the complete relief from miseries would be absolutely impossible and all Gurus and scriptures from time immemorial would become unnecessary and in vain!

Some, believing that Jnana can be obtained only through Prarabdha, live lazily, i.e., not even desiring to obtain Jnana. But such people show their laziness only so far as their desires and efforts towards obtaining Jnana are concerned, putting the blame on Prarabdha and being at the mercy of Prarabdha’s grace! But at the same time they never show laziness towards their worldly activities, i.e., they show their enterprising spirit in trying to obstruct the function of Prarabdha (to lessen the miseries and to increase the happiness that come through Prarabdha), which can never be obstructed or altered. The net result will be NIL. They who are so enterprising in doing what they

need not and should not do, are lazy in doing what they necessarily should do – the effort to destroy the doership by Self-attention. This is the pinnacle of ignorance! Therefore, those who have faith in God should be enterprising in surrendering the doership to Him, others in enquiring into the Self which is the only right use of their ‘freedom to will and act.’

But some among us may ask: “By the limited knowing power (Alpa-Chit-Shakti) of the individual which is merely an imaginary reflection of the power of the True and un-limited Knowledge (Akhanda-ChitShakti), it is impossible to attain the State of Perfection (the Supreme). Is not the Grace of the power of that True unlimited Knowledge which Itself is God or Guru necessary?” Yes, indeed it is necessary! Because help is needed, IT gives help to those who have faith in God, in their efforts to surrender their ‘I-ness’, by bestowing upon them a tremendous capacity to surrender. 

This is what is meant by the saying, “Take one step towards God; He will take ten steps towards you.” While to the aspirant who, though having no faith in God or Guru, makes intense effort, with enthusiasm, in enquiring into the Self, his Reality, the Self acts as Guru and gives help from within as well as from without (external). IT shines in the form of that clarity of understanding that makes him understand through the outer events in his life, that the outgoing attention IS only misery. IT shines in the form of Bliss within and makes him turn within towards IT and know ‘This Bliss is my real state’, thus attracting him to merely BE. In this way the Grace of the Guru or God helps even him from within and without.

189

“Verily the Self is the Supreme Principle (Reality). Do Thou, Thyself reveal this to me, O Arunachala”. – Arunachala Akshramanamalai - Verse 43

Therefore let neither of these two types of aspirants be worried about the scarcity of the Grace of the Supreme.

 That Supreme Grace is ever ready to flow - to say the truth,

 It is ever-flowing. 

This Revealing is always possible and done by Grace only.

 Pain and pleasure may come according to Prarabdha; but the aspirant ever has his own freedom to remain in that centre, from where he cannot be moved by them: for, this alone he has freedom and not for obstructing the function of Prarabdha. 

When the ‘freedom to will and act’ is applied to like and to make efforts to BE STILL, the doership is destroyed.

 Along with the doership, the experiencership, which is necessary to experience all the three karmas, is also destroyed.

 Only with this freedom can we reach the Goal; should this freedom not be there, there would be no hope. 

This Freedom alone – which is nothing but GRACE – paves the way for us to be freed from karmas. This alone is the real secret of the karmas.

 Thus should we know! 


...................................

190 Self Effort

.................

The self-effort in destroying the karmas, is attending to the Self. 

We can say that Awakening or Liberation is “Being aware of the Self” (for, Self and Its Awareness are one and the same). Suppose a man is said to have awakened from sleep or dream; what does it mean? It means that he has returned to his self-

awareness (body-consciousness), in which he was before his sleep or dream, i.e., that he has returned from the dream-body and dream world-consciousness to the present body and world-consciousness which is their root. 

What makes a person who is having a dream wake up? There are two causes:- 

(1) When the karma which started (to give fruit) a dream comes to an end, the dream ends either in sleep or in waking. 

(2) When, due to the shock of extreme fear, happiness or misery experienced during a dream it happens that the attention of the dreamer* is knowingly or unknowingly drawn towards himself, the first person in the dream, i. e., his mind or attention is forced to return to the Heart, i.e., towards the first person in the dream. So also when the Prarabdha which started the present waking state (life) is exhausted, this waking state (life) comes to an end, i.e., to the state of death, like a dream ends in sleep. In this way, the ending of Prarabdha will end only this waking state but cannot give the Awakening.

192

If one turns one’s attention towards the first person (the subject) in the waking state, the waking should come to an end, leaving one in the State of Awakening. This Self-ward turn is Being only, and not doing; hence it is not a thought or karma.

Only this kind of Self-effort is called the effort of destroying karmas. 

This alone will lead to Liberation. 

As all other efforts of attention are  towards second and third persons objects, they are only generating karmas and will not give Liberation. Such is the truth! 

Yet, some of us used to say that even Jnana, the Awakening, is the result of Prarabdha. It is wrong. Jnana is not bound by, but transcending the results of karmas. The aforesaid second kind of Self-effort will be known as the Natural State (Sahaja State) when it is found to be going on effortlessly. This is the state of Effortless-effort – Dynamic Stillness.



................

verse 69 of ‘The Bridal Garland of Letters’ : “Do Thou grant me Thy full union with me so that my mind which is filled with worldly tendencies, may be filled with the tendency for Perfection, Thy True Nature, O Arunachala!

Therefore, let no one ‘depend upon Prarabdha for Liberation. Liberation is in no way connected with Prarabdha. Prarabdha belongs to the face of experiencership concerning the fruit of action which is in direct opposition to Selfeffort as shown in the diagram. But Liberation is solely connected with the non-tendency -”Beingness in nature’, 

i.e., Liberation is possible through the resumption of the tendency’ Beingness-in-nature’ the state of Doing-lessness or Actionless - action, (i.e., doershipless-action) which is the correct spiritual practice for Liberation, the right Self-attention.

From what has been said above, we must realize the facts that Liberation is not at all bound by Prarabdha and that the strength of such spiritual practice (Atma-Sadhana) done in past births, will resume itself and help one in the present birth also. Therefore, without doubting whether there is room for Liberation in our Prarabdha and being depressed over it by trying to read the Prarabdha through astrology, palmistry, I-chin, numerology etc, (for, these arts and crafts cannot reveal it), let us turn Self-ward with great courage and attain Liberation through the tendency ‘Beingness-in-nature’.


.....

202

Explanatory Notes on Verse 6 of ‘Shri Arunachala Ashtakam’ Verse 6: 

“O Heart, the Light of Self-Awareness! Thou, the only Thing (Being), alone art. In Thee is a wondrous Power which is none other than Thee. From It rise, by the whirl of Prarabdha, series of subtle (atom-like), dark, mist-like thoughts illumined by the reflected light of the mind. These mists are seen as shadowy pictures of (subtle) world within, on the mirror of this mind-light and, as the pictures of material world outside projected though the five senses such as eyes etc., just like a cinema show projected through a lens. O Hill of Grace, let them appear or let them not appear; what does it matter? They are not apart from Thee.” 

Arunachala, the Heart, is the only Thing that exists. “It is the Light of Self-Awareness.

‘The Five Gems to Shri Arunachala (Shri Arunachala Pancharatnam)’ by Shri Bhagavan Ramana;”... Engulfing the entire universe (of names and forms) with the spreading rays of the light of Supreme Knowledge...”. It is thus taught that the pictures of the world (of dyads and triads) cannot exist in the original light of the Self. Therefore, when asked in verse 10 of ‘Ulladu Narpadu’ “To whom are the ignorance and knowledge?” We should be able to reply that it is only for the ego.

We should also know that, if the ego is enquired into as to what it is, it will disappear, and thus seeing the non-existence of the ego, is the right understanding of the base of dyads and triads and when thus we understand; the Self-Knowledge dawns, and dyads and triads disappear. In the light of the Self the base of dyads and triads, i. e., the ego, itself is found to be non-existent and hence along with it the non-existence of the dyads and triads. When, Self, the absolute base is experienced, ego the base of dyads and triads will 

disappear. As the conclusion of the commentators does not go against the final truth, we have to console ourselves in knowing that their writing will not greatly mislead the reader; but the reader should understand that the intention of Shri Bhagavan is to tell us that the base of the dyads and triads is the ego, and not the Self.

...........................

Verse 8 : “If one worships the Supreme in whatever form, giving Him whatever name, it is the way to see the Supreme in that name and form; yet, realizing one’s own truth in the truth of that True Thing (the Supreme) and being one with It, having been resolved into It, is the True Seeing (Realization). Thus should you know!” 

“The appearance of the world in dream, waking, our whole life, and the creation as well as the non appearance of the world in swoon, sleep, death and dissolution are not apart from Thee, the Self Awareness, O Arunachala, the Hill of Grace!” 

.....................................................    ......................................